Annex 10: Responses to targeted consultation question 15

• Author: Fabien Roques - Helene Laroche
• Pages: 113-116

Com bined ret rosp ectiv e ev aluat ion and prosp ecti ve im pact asse ssmen t su ppor t st udy on Emission

Trad ing Syst em ( ETS) Stat e Aid Guidelin es

113

Annex 1 0: Respon ses to target ed consultation question

15

Tabl e 21: Responses t o target ed consulta tion question 15

“What ar e the m er its of m odu lating t he aid int en sit y based on t he d if ferent sect or s'

tr ade intensi ty?”

Sector

Su mm ary of th e r espo nse s

05 .10 - Mi ning of

har d co al

N/ A

05 .20 - Mi ning of

lignite

I t con tri but es t o pr eserv ing inte rnat iona lly comp etit ive indu stri es wi thi n

th e EU.

07 .10 - Mi ning of

ir on or es

Tra de in tens ity, an in dicat or of ex por ts le vel in r elat ion t o im por ts, is n ot

a m easu re of car bon l eakage expos ure risk . The carb on l eakag e

exp osur e ri sk ass essmen t shou ld f ocus on t hree pill ars, as d escrib ed in

th e fr ame work for qu alit ativ e asses smen ts: abat eme nt p oten tia l, mar ket

cha ract erist ics, profi t m arg ins.

07 .29 - Mi ning of

ot her non- fer rous

m etal ores

Tra de in tens ity, an in dicat or of ex por ts le vel in r elat ion t o im por ts, is n ot

a m easu re of car bon l eakage expos ure risk . The carb on l eakag e

exp osur e ri sk ass essmen t shou ld f ocus on t hree pill ars: aba tem ent

pot ent ial, mark et c haracte rist ics, profi t m arg ins.

08 .91 - Mi ning of

chem ical and

fer til iser min erals

In EU-ETS t he car bon leak age l ist i s key fo r t he al locat ion of f ree

all owan ces. I t is t o be pref erre d to avo id new /a ddit iona l cri teri a fo r t he

ind irect cost s co mpen sati on.

08 .93 - Ex tra ction

of salt

I f fu nds t o co mpen sate for carb on l eakag e ri sks ex ist it seem s log ical t o

com pensa te s ector s m ore th at h ave high tr ade i nten sity an d hig h

car bon leaka ge r isk. We prop ose t hat if ther e is car bon le akage risk

bey ond a cer tain lev el t hen comp ensat ion is ne eded.

08 .99 - Ot her

mini ng a nd

quarr yin g n. e.c.

Sam e as 07. 29 - Min ing of ot her non -ferr ous m eta l or es

10 .41 -

Manu fact ure of o ils

and fat s

N/ A

10 .62 -

Manu fact ure of

sta rches and

sta rch prod ucts

Tra de in tens ity is not a m easur e of carb on l eakag e ex posur e ri sk. The

car bon leaka ge ex posur e r isk a ssessment sho uld focus on t hre e pil lars:

abat eme nt pot ent ial, mark et ch aract eri stics and profi t m argi ns.

10 .81 -

Manu fact ure of

sugar

As t her e is no m odul atio n pl anned for th e Carb on Le akage risks secto rs

in the fre e all ocati on, it w ould not be suit able for indi rect cost

com pensati on.

11 .06 -

Manu fact ure of

malt

Tra de in tens ity is not a m easur e of carb on l eakag e ex posur e ri sk. The

car bon leaka ge ex posur e r isk a ssessment sho uld focus on t hre e pil lars:

abat eme nt pot ent ial, mark et ch aract eri stics and profi t m argi ns.

13 .10 -

Prepara tion and

spin ning of text ile

fibres

N/ A

13 .95 -

Manu fact ure of

non -wo vens and

arti cles m ade from

non -wo vens,

exc ept appar el

N/ A

14. 11 -

Manu fact ure of

lea ther clot hes

N/ A