A relação entre União Europeia e a questão prioritária de constitucionalidade do direito francês
Author | Paula Wojcikiewicz Almeida |
Pages | 165-187 |
A RELAÇÃO ENTRE UNIÃO EUROPEIA
E A QUESTÃO PRIORITÁRIA DE CONSTITUCIONALIDADE
DO DIREITO FRANCÊS
LÍVIA DA SILVA FERREIRA1*
!"#$%&
!" #$%&'$" %&" ($)*+$'&" %&" ($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&" 0+/)(1," ,&+2-." 3$+" /)$," ($#$"
&4'$"%$"5)-($" ,-,*/")$"6./'" $"&4/#&"%&" ($#3/*-7-'-%/%&"&)*+&")$+#/,"
-)0+/($),*-*.(-$)/-," &" $" *&4*$" %/" 8$),*-*.-9:$" &+/" +&/'-;/%$" 3&'$" 8$),&'
8$),*-*.(-$)/'"=" >+?:$"3$'@*-($"=" %&"#/)&-+/"3+&2&)*-2/A" 8$#$"+&,.'*/%$" %/"
0/'*/"%&"3+$*&9:$"%$,"%-+&-*$,"&"'-7&+%/%&,"($),*-*.(-$)/-,B"/"8$),*-*.-9:$"C+/)D
(&,/"%&"EFGH"0$-"?+/%./'#&)*&"3&+%&)%$",./",.3+/(-/A"I#"JKKH"0$-"/3+$2/D
%/".#/"L&-"8$),*-*.(-$)/'"6.&"-),&+-.")$"$+%&)/#&)*$"M.+@%-($"0+/)(1,"/"N.&,D
*:$"O+-$+-*P+-/"%&"8$),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&B"#&(/)-,#$"6.&" ($)0&+&"/$,"'-*-?/)*&,"/"
3+&++$?/*-2/"%&"($)*&,*/+" /"($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&"%&" .#/"%-,3$,-9:$"'&?-,'/*-2/"
6.&"M.'?.",&+"2-$'/%$+/"%&",&.,"%-+&-*$,"&"'-7&+%/%&,"($),*-*.(-$)/-,B"(+-/)%$"
/,,-#".#" #$%&'$"%&" ($)*+$'&"%&" ($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&"+&3+&,,-2$A" I,*&"&,*.%$"
/)/'-,/"/," (/+/(*&+@,*-(/,"%/"NO8" &",./," +&'/9Q&,"($#" $"MP"&4-,*&)*&" ($)*+$'&"
%&"($)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&" ="6.&"&4/#-)/" /"($#3/*-7-'-%/%&" &)*+&"($#3+$#-,,$,"
-)*&+)/(-$)/-,"&"/" '&-"-)*&+)/"="&" %&"6.&"#/)&-+/" &,*&,"%$-,"*-3$,"%&" ($)*+$'&B"
*:$"3/+&(-%$,B",&"($#3/*-7-'-;/#"&"($&4-,*A
'()(*+(#,-.(*"
8$)*+$'&" %&" 8$),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&R" S-+&-*$" 8$),*-*.(-$)/'" C+/)(1,R" T&0$+#/" %/"
8$),*-*.-9:$"C+/)(&,/R"S-+&-*$,"&"L-7&+%/%&,"8$),*-*.(-$)/-,R"N.&,*:$"O+-$+-*PD
+-/"%&"8$),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&R" 8$)*+$'&"%&"8$)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&R"S-+&-*$" 8$#.)-*PD
+-$R"U)-:$"I.+$3&-/A
/010234+&5$67&
!"*+/7/' V"+&,.'*/%$"%$"-)*&+&,,&"" +&/'-;/+".#/"3&,6.-,/"6.&"&)D
2$'2&"$" %-+&-*$" ($),*-*.(-$)/'" 0+/)(1," &" $" %-+&-*$" &.+$3&.B" ($),-%&+/)%$" 6.&"
/"T&357'-(/" C+/)(&,/"=" 6.&"%&,%&" EFGH"#/)*-)" $"($)*+$'&" %&"($),*-*.(-$D
E" W&,*+/""X&$+-/"%$"I,*/%$"&"S-+&-*$"8$),*-*.(-$)/'"3&'/"OU8DT-$"&"?+/%./%/""S-+&-*$"3&'/"
CYZ"S[TI[X!"T[!A"O&,6.-,/%$+/")$"3+$M&*$"\.3+$""]5#&+$,B"%/"CYZ"S[TI[X!"T[!A
E^^"TIZ[\X_"S!"OT!YT_W_"SI"S[TI[X!"S_"U][`!"IUT!OI[_
)/'-%/%&"%&"'&-," &4('.,-2/#&)*&"3+&2&)*-2$" ="/"3/+*-+" %&"JKEK"3/,,$." /"+&/'-D
;/+"*/#7V#"$"($)*+$'&"%&"($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&" %/,"'&-,"a posterioriA"_"T&0$+#/"
8$),*-*.(-$)/'"C+/)(&,/"*&2&"-)@(-$""JKKHB"0$-"-),&+-%/")$"$+%&)/#&)*$"M.+@D
%-($"0+/)(1,"3&'/"L&-"8$),*-*.(-$)/'" )a"JKKHDbJc"%&"Jd"%&"M.' %&"JKKHB"eL&-"
%&"#$%&+)-;/9:$"%/,"-),*-*.-9Q&,"%/"Zf"T&387'-(/gB"&"(+-$."/"4XpVWLRQ3ULRULWDL*
re de Constitutionnalité"hN.&,*:$"O+-$+-*P+-/"%&"8$),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&"="NO8JiA
_"3/'/2+/"3+-$+-*P+-/dB"%&"/($+%$"($#"$"%-(-$)P+-$"O+-7&+/#"%/"L@)?./"O$+D
WXJXHVD VLJQL´FD TXH JR]D GH XPD SULRULGDGH VREUH RV RXWURV 1R PHVPR
VHQWLGRYDOH FLWDURVLJQL´FDGR HQFRQWUDGRQR GLFLRQiULRGHSRUWXJXrV RQOLQH0
W-(&'-,B")$" 6./'"/" 3/'/2+/" 3+-$+-*P+-/cp GH´QLGDFRPR TXHWHP SULRULGDGH
\&?.)%$"$"%-(-$)P+-$"$)'-)&"%&" 3$+*.?.1,"j$./-,,B"3+-$+-*P+-/GWDPEpPpGH´D
)-%/"($#$k"/6.&'/"6.&"*"3+-$+-%/%&A
]&,*&",&)*-%$B" 2/'&"(-*/+"/-)%/" 6.&"eprioritaire”6" ,&?.)%$"$" %-(-$)P+-$"L&"
3HWLW5REHUWHPWUDGXomROLYUHVLJQL´FD©TXHWHPSULRULGDGHH©TXHYHP
"3+-#&-+$"3$+"$+%"%&"-#3$+*l)(-/A
I,*/"3+-$+-%/%&"+&,-%&")/"-#3$+*l)(-/" %$"6.&,*-$)/#&)*$"%&"($),*-*.(-$D
)/'-%/%&B"6.&B".#/"2&;" /3+&,&)*/%$"3$+".#"M.+-,%-(-$)/%$" %&)*+$"%&".#"3+$D
(&,,$"" (.+,$B"%&2&" ,&+"/)/'-,/%$" %&"-#&%-/*$" &"$" +&0&+-%$"3+$(&,,$" 6.&" $"
RULJLQRXGHYHVHUVXVSHQVRDWpDGHFLVmR´QDODUHVSHLWRGDFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDGH
%/"%-,3$,-9:$" '&?-,'/*-2/" ,&+"($)*&,*/%/A" !" +&0&+-%$"&)*&)%-#&)*$" V" /3$-/%$"
3$+"W/+("Y.-''/.#&B"\&(+&*P+-$"Y&+/'"%$"8$),&'
FDUiWHUSULRULWiULRGD43&VLJQL´FD TXHHOD“doit 1*+& regardée prioritairement
avant toute autre” 7A
J" eNO8k"6.&,*:$"3+-$+-*P+-/"%&"($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&A"I,*/"/7+&2-/9:$",$/"&,*+/)"&"(&+*/#&)D
WHFDUHFHGHHOHJkQFLD1RHQWDQWRYDLVHLPSRUUDSLGDPHQWHQRVDQ´WHDWURVHWHPSORVQDV
+&2-,*/,"%&"M.+-,3+.%1)(-/B")$,"(.++@(.'$,"%&"&),-)$B")$,"&,(+-*>+-$,"%&"/%2$?/%$,B")/,",/'/,"
GHDXGLrQFLDHDFXUWRSUD]RHPWRGDVDVSUR´VV}HVGRGLUHLWR«7UDGXomROLYUHGRDXWRU
""Z&+,:$"$+-?-)/'k" 43& TXHVWLRQSULRULWDLUH GH FRQVWLWXWLRQQDOLWp&H VLJOHUpVRQH EL]DU*
rement et manque assurément d’elegance. Il va pourtant s’imposer rapidement dans les
amphithéatres, les revues de jurisprudence, les programmes d’enseignement, les cabinets
d’avocats, les salles d’audience, bref, dans toutes les professions du droit."hT!U\\I_UB"S$D
#-)-6.&A"m!]]IXB"n.'-&)A" Lo&,,&)(-&'"%&"'/"NO8A" W$%&"%o'$-"%&" '/"N.&,*-$)"O+-$+-*/-+&"
%&"8$),*-*.*-$))/'-*VA0Jf"&%BA"O/+-,k"Y./'-)$B"JKEJB"3AEEiA
d" O+-p$p+-p*Pp+-p$"h0+/)(1,"3+-$+-*/-+&iA" _%M&*-2$k N.&"?$;/" %&".#/"3+-$+-%/%&" ,$7+&"$,"$.*+$,A"
ª3ULRULWiULD«B"-)"%-(-$)P+-$"O+-7&+/#"%/"L@)?./"O$+*.?.&,/A"
c" O+-A$A+-A*PA+-A$"/%M"h'/*"#&%"3+-$+-*h/*&iqP+-$iA"N.&"*"3+-$+-%/%&B"-)"%-(-$)P+-$"%&"3$+*.?.1,"
$)'-)&"W-(&'-,A
G" O+-$+-*P+-$"D"/%MA"N.&"*"3+-$+-%/%&B"-)"%-(-$)P+-$"$)'-)&"%&"3$+*.?.1,"j$./-,,A
^" !"#$"#%"'( 1."N.-"/"'/"3+-$+-*VA"Le véhicule venant de la droite est prioritaire."Personne priori*
WDLUH68%678QXQHSULRULWDLUH9RLHSULRULWDLUHRORQDODSULRULWp4XLYLHQWHQSUHPLHU
par ordre d’importance, d’urgence. Secteur économique prioritaire.Objectif prioritaire. )*+,"
PRIORITAIREMENT, in Le Petit Robert Dictionnaire de La Langue Française.
b" YU[LL_UWI"W/+(B"r"NO8k"*&4*&,"/33'-(/7'&,"&*"3+-s+&,"%V(-,-$),"tB"L&,")$.2&/.4"(/
%."8$),&-'" ($),*-*.*-$))&'B")a" JFB"%$,,-&+"k" '/"6.&,*-$)" 3+-$+-*/-+&"%&" ($),*-*.*-$))/'-*VB"3A"
JA"S-,3$)@2&'"k"
3%0u($),&-'D($),*-*.*-$))&'DGJbdKA3%0"
"_"TIL_x`!"I]XTI"U][`!"IUT!OI[_"I"_"NUI\X `!"OT[!T[XyT[_""E^b"
"SI"8!]\X[XU8[!]_L[S_SI"S!"S[TI[X!"CT_]8z\
_"L&-"!+?l)-(/" ){"JKKFDEGJdB"3.7'-(/%/" "EE"%&" %&;+$"%&"JKKFB" +&D
?.'/#&)*$." /" L&-" 8$),*-*.(-$)/'" &" &,*/7&'&(&." /," ($)%-9Q&," 3/+/" /3'-(/9:$"
%$"/+*-?$" ^EDE" %/"8$),*-*.-9:$B" &" /"NO8" &)*+$." "2-?$+" " E{"%&" #/+9$" %&"
JKEK"(+-/)%$" )$" ,-,*/"M.+@%-($" 0+/)(1,"$" ($)*+$'&" %&"($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&" a
posteriori"$."+&3+&,,-2$A" C$-"%&*&+#-)/%$"3&'/"L&-" 8$),*-*.(-$)/'"6.&"$">+?:$"
($#3&*&)*&"3/+/"&4/#-)/+" $,"6.&,*-$)/#&)*$,",&+-/"$" 8$),&'
)/'"C+/)(1,B"6.&"MP"+&/'-;/2/"$"($)*+$'&"a prioriA
!($++&"6.&" /"NO8"):$" 3$%&",&+" $"#&(/)-,#$" .*-'-;/%$"3/+/"$" &4/#&"
%&"($)0$+#-%/%&"&)*+&"($#3+$#-,,$,"-)*&+)/(-$)/-,"&"/"'&-"-)*&+)/"0+/)(&,/B"
2-,*$"6.&" /"+&/'-;/9:$"%&,*&" ($)*+$'&",&" %P"3$+"#&-$" %$"e($)*+$'&"%&" ($)D
2&)(-$)/'-%/%&"%&"'&-,gB" 6.&"V"+&/'-;/%$" 3&'$,"*+-7.)/-,"M.%-(-/-," &"/%#-)-,D
*+/*-2$,"0+/)(&,&,A
'HVWDPDQHLUDDLPSRUWkQFLD HMXVWL´FDWLYDGRSUHVHQWHWUDEDOKRUHVLGHP
QRLQWHUHVVH HPHVWXGDUFRPR D43& VHDGpTXD jVUHJUDVGR %ORFR(XURSHX
&"($#$"%&"0/*$" $($++&"/"-)*&+/9:$"&)*+&"$," %$-,",-,*/,A"!,"$7M&*-2$,"3+-)(-D
3/-,"%&,*&"*+/7/' ,:$B"3$+",./" 2&;B"/)/'-,/+"/," (/+/(*&+@,*-(/,"%/"NO8" ($#$"
#&(/)-,#$"3/+/"3+$*&?&+" $,"%-+&-*$," &"'-7&+%/%&,"0.)%/#&)*/-," ($),/?+/%$,"
FRQVWLWXFLRQDOPHQWHEHP FRPR WDPEpP LGHQWL´FDU VH R FRQWUROH UHSUHVVLYR
LQWURGX]LGRSHOD43&GHDOJXPDPDQHLUDJHUDFRQµLWRVRXLQFRPSDWLELOLGDGHV
($#"$"MP"&4-,*&)*&"($)*+$'&"%&"($)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&A
L$?$B" $" *+/7/'
8$),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&"&"&43'-(/+" $",&."#&(/)-,#$"%&" 0.)(-$)/#&)*$B"$,"'&?-D
*-#/%$,"3/+/"/3+&,&)*PD'/B"$,"*+-7.)/-," ($#3&*&)*&,"3/+/"+&(&71D'/B"/,")$+D
#/,"6.&" 3$%",&+"$7M&*$" %&".#" 6.&,*-$)/#&)*$"",&%&" %&"NO8B" /,,-#"
($#$"/,")$+#/,"($),*-*.(-$)/-,"6.&"3$%",&+"-)2$(/%/,"",&%&"%&"NO8B"
/'V#"%&"/3+&,&)*/+"/,"($),&6.1)(-/,"%&".#/" %&(-,:$"%&"NO8"&",&.,"3+-)(-D
3/-,"&0&-*$,A
O$,*&+-$+#&)*&B"$" *+/7/' -+P"&43$+" $," 6.&,*-$)/#&)*$,"'&2/)*/%$," )$"
-)*.-*$" %&" ($),*/*/+" ,&" $" ($)*+$'&" %/" N.&,*:$" O+-$+-*P+-/" %&" 8$),*-*.(-$)/'-D
%/%&"V"/)*/?|)-($"&" $0&+&(&"+-,($,"%&"($)*+/%-9:$"" +&'/9:$"/$"($)*+$'&"%&"
($)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&" +&/'-;/%$" 3&'$," *+-7.)/-," $+%-)P+-$," )$" %-+&-*$" &.+$3&.B" &"
YHUL´FDUiDR´QDOVHDFRH[LVWrQFLDSDFt´FDGHDPERVRVFRQWUROHVpSRVVtYHO
9010:&34+&)"05"0-&3#4;4$-;&3();5(5"0<0-&34+&)"05"0
-&3*"3-;&3();5(5"
].#" 3+-#&-+$" #$#&)*$" $" 3+&,&)*&" *+/7/'
($) O+-$+-*P+-/"%&" 8$),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&"&" &43$+",./," 3+-)(-3/-,"
(/+/(*&+@,*-(/,B"($#$" ,&"%P" ,&."0.)(-$)/#&)*$B" /'V#"%&" /3$)*/+"$," &0&-*$,"&"
($),&6.1)(-/,"%&".#/"%&(-,:$"",&%&"%&"NO8A
E^H"TIZ[\X_"S!"OT!YT_W_"SI"S[TI[X!"S_"U][`!"IUT!OI[_
©2TXHpDTXHVWmRSULRULWiULDGHFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDGH"
_" NO8" V" .#" #/+($A" I'/" *+$.4&" ($),-?$" #.%/)9/," &,3&+/%/,"
M.+-,%-(-$)/%$,"0+/)(&,&,"6.&"($)2-2-/#"($#"0+&6.&)*&," 2-$'/9Q&,"%&",&.,"%-D
+&-*$,"&"'-7&+%/%&,"($),*-*.(-$)/-,A
8$)*.%$B".#/"+&,,/'2/"V"%&" (.) /3'-(/"5)-(/"&"&4('.D
,-2/#&)*&"/$,"%-+&-*$,"&"'-7&+%/%&,"($),*-*.(-$)/-,A"S&" 0/*$B"($#"/"-)*+$%.9:$"
%$"($)*+$'&" %&" ($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&" +&3+&,,-2$" )$" ,-,*/" 0+/)(1,B" /" +&0$+#/"
FRQVWLWXFLRQDO IRL VLJQL´FDWLYD 3RUpP HVVD PRGDOLGDGH GH FRQWHVWDomR SRU
3/+*-(.'/+&,B"%/,"'&-," MP"3+$#.'?/%/," 3&'$"O/+'/#&)*$"):$" V"-++&,*+-*/A"I'/" ):$"
3$%&",&+" .*-'-;/%/" 3/+/" 6.&,*-$)/+" /" ($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&" %&" *$%/" &" 6./'6.&+"
%-,3$,-9:$" '&?-,'/*-2/B" $." ,&M/B" $" 0.)%/#&)*$" %&" 2/'-%/%&" %/" NO8" +&,-%&" )/"
2-$'/9:$"%-+&*/"%&" %-+&-*$,"&"'-7&+%/%&,"?/+/)*-%$," 3&'$"*&4*$"($),*-*.(-$)/'" &"
3&'/,")$+#/,"%&"+&0&+1)(-/A
-,.,./0/1&"&2%'"34%#2&4/*&/562
_"-)*+$%.9:$" %/" NO8")$" $+%&)/#&)*$" M.+@%-($"0+/)(1," ,&"%&." 3$+" #&-$"%$,"
/+*-?$,"JHB"JF"&" dK"%/"L&-"8$),*-*.(-$)/'" %&"W$%&+)-;/9:$"%/,"[),*-*.-9Q&," %/"
N.-)*/"T&357'-(/"){"JKKHDbJc"%&"Jd"%&"M.' JKKHA"U#/"&)%/"($),*-*.D
(-$)/'"(/+/(*&+-;/%/"($#$"e#$%&+)-;/%$+/g"):$"3$%&+-/"*&+"$.*+$"$7M&*-2$"6.&"
QmRRGHDWXDOL]DUHGDUYHUVDWLOLGDGHjVDQWLJDVLQVWLWXLo}HVIUDQFHVDV
$DOWHUDomRQRWH[WRGD&RQVWLWXLomR)UDQFHVDGHHPUHODomRj4XHVD
*:$"O+-$+-*P+-/"%&" 8$),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&"$($++&."($#" /"-),&+9:$"%$"/+*-?$" ^EDE"&"
/'*&+/9:$"%$"/+*-?$"^Jk
_TX[Y!"^EDE
N./)%$B")$"l#7-*$" %&".#"3+$(&,,$" 3&)%&)*&"3&+/)*&".#" >+?:$"M.D
+-,%-(-$)/'B" V" /+?.#&)*/%$" 6.&" .#/" %-,3$,-9:$" '&?-,'/*-2/" /#&/9/"
%-+&-*$,"&"'-7&+%/%&,"?/+/)*-%$,"3&'/"8$),*-*.-9:$B"$"8$),&'
*.(-$)/'"3$%&",&+"($)2$(/%$"3/+/"/)/'-,/+"$"(/,$"3$+"#&-$"%&"(-*/9:$"
%$"8$),&'$."%$"\.3+$"X+-7.)/'B"6.&",&"3+$).)(-/""
.#"3+/;$"%&*&+#-)/%$A
U#/"'&-" $+?l)-(/"%&*&+#-)/" /," ($)%-9Q&,"%&" /3'-(/9:$"%$" 3+&D
,&)*&"/+*-?$A
_TX[Y!"^J
U#/"%-,3$,-9:$"%&('/+/%/"-)($),*-*.(-$)/'"($#"7/,&")$"/+*-?$"^E"):$"
3$%&",&+"3+$#.'?/%/"$."&4&(.*/%/A
U#/" %-,3$,-9:$" %&('/+/%/" -)($),*-*.(-$)/'" ($#" 7/,&" )$" /+*-D
?$"^EDE" V"+&2$?/%/" /" ($)*/+"%/" 3.7'-(/9:$"%/" %&(-,:$"%$" 8$),&'
&RQVWLWXFLRQDORX GHXPD GDWD SRVWHULRU´[DGD SRUHVWD GHFLVmR2
"_"TIL_x`!"I]XTI"U][`!"IUT!OI[_"I"_"NUI\X `!"OT[!T[XyT[_""E^F"
"SI"8!]\X[XU8[!]_L[S_SI"S!"S[TI[X!"CT_]8z\
8$),&' %&*&+#-)/"/," ($)%-9Q&,"&" '-#-*&,")$," 6./-,"
$,"&0&-*$,"6.&"/"%-,3$,-9:$"3+$%.;-.",:$",.,(&3*@2&-,"%&",&+"6.&,D
*-$)/%$,A
_,"%&(-,Q&,"%$"8$),&',.M&-*/,"/"+&(.+D
,$A"[#3QD,&"/$,"3$%&+&,"357'-($,"&"*$%/,"/,"/.*$+-%/%&,"/%#-)-,D
*+/*-2/,"&"M.+-,%-(-$)/-,A
!," %$.*+-)/%$+&," 0+/)(&,&," S$#-)-6.&" T$.,,&/." &" n.'-&)" m$))&*" &'/D
7$+/+/#" .#" #/)./'" %&" /3'-(/9:$" %/" N.&,*:$" O+-$+-*P+-/" %&" 8$),*-*.(-$)/D
'-%/%&")$" 6./'"/7$+%/+/#"$," 3+-)(-3/-,"3$)*$," ($)(&+)&)*&,"/$"#&(/)-,#$"
%&"($)*+$'&"%&"($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&" a posteriori, $,"6./-,",&+:$" &,*.%/%$,")$"
3+&,&)*&"*>3-($A
8$#"$"/%2&)*$"%/",.3+/(-*/%/"L&-"8$),*-*.(-$)/'B"*$%/" 2&;"6.&".#"3/+*-D
(.'/+B"%&,%&" 6.&",&M/"3/+*&" ".#"3+$(&,,$" M.%-(-/'"$." /%#-)-,*+/*-2$B"($),-D
%&+&"6.&".#/"%-,3$,-9:$"'&?-,'/*-2/"2-$'/"/'?.#"%&",&.,"%-+&-*$,"$." '-7&+%/%&,"
?/+/)*-%$,"3&'/" 8$),*-*.-9:$B"&,*&" 3/,,/" /"3$%&+" 6.&,*-$)/+"/" ($),*-*.(-$)/D
'-%/%&" %/" +&0&+-%/" %-,3$,-9:$B" &" &,,&" 6.&,*-$)/#&)*$B" 3$+" ,./" 2&;B" *$+)/D,&"
-#&%-/*/#&)*&".#/"6.&,*:$"3+-$+-*P+-/"%&"($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&A
S&,*/"0$+#/B"*" '&?-*-#-%/%&"3/+/"$0&+&(&+" .#/"NO8B"%&" /($+%$"($#"/"
L&-"!+?l)-(/"){"JKKFDEGJdk
/i"!"($)M.)*$"%&"'-*-?/)*&,HB"&"):$"/3&)/,"(-%/%:$,FA"I,*&"($)M.)*$"+&3+&D
,&)*/"/," 3&,,$/,"0@,-(/,B06./'6.&+" 6.&",&M/" /")/(-$)/'-%/%&B"%&,%&" 6.&",&M/#"
/.*$+&,"$."+V.,"".#"3+$(&,,$EKR
7i"O&,,$/,"M.+@%-(/,"3$%"/3+&,&)*/+".#/"NO8"($#$".#/"/,,$(-/9:$"$."
FRPRVLQGLFDWRSUR´VVLRQDOEER
(i"!,"*&+(&-+$,"3$%"-?./'#&)*&"-)*&+2-+B"%&"/($+%$"($#"/"/3'-(/9:$"%/,"
+&?+/,"3+>3+-/,"%&"(/%/"$+%"M.+-,%-(-$)/'"h/%#-)-,*+/*-2/"$."M.%-(-/'iR
G1R FXUVR GHXP SURFHVVR SHQDOR 0LQLVWpULR3~EOLFR p SRUGH´QLomR
.#/"3/+*&"&" 3$%&"*&$+-(/#&)*&"/3+&,&)*/+" .#/"NO8A"]$" &)*/)*$B")/"3+P*-(/B"
)&)<. o>
0/(-'#&)*&"&)*&)%-%$B" .#/" 2&;"6.&" /" 0.)9:$"3+-)(-3/'" %$" >+?:$"V" ?/+/)*-+" /"
($++&*/"/3'-(/9:$"%/"'&-"&"):$"($)*&,*/+"/",./" ($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&A"]/,"*&D
H" T&0&+&D,&"/"6./'6.&+" 3&,,$/"(/3/;"%&" +&($) $,",&.,"%-+&-*$," "*+-7.)/'A"
Z&+,:$"$+-?-)/'k"Se"%-*"%&"*$.*&"3&+,$))&"3$.2/)*"0/-+&"+&($))/}*+&"&*"&4&+(&+",&,"%+$-*,"&)"
M.,*-(&A"S-,3$)@2&'"k"
$TXDOLGDGHGH FLGDGmRQR GLUHLWRIUDQFrVHVWi UHODFLRQDGDjREWHQomR GDQDFLRQDOLGDGH
IUDQFHVDVHMDSRU´OLDomRQDWXUDOL]DomRRXSRURSomR9HUVmRRULJLQDO La qualité de citoyen
HVWOLpHjOREWHQWLRQGHODQDWLRQDOLWpSDU´OLDWLRQSDUODQDWXUDOLVDWLRQRXSDURSWLRQS-,3$D
)@2&'"k"
EK" 8$),&'
EE" 8$),&'%&"EF"%&"#/-$"%&"JKEKA"\&9:$"C+/)(&,/"%&"!7,&+2/*>+-$"[)*&+D
)/(-$)/'"%&"O+-,Q&,B"){"dJdFdKA
EbK"TIZ[\X_"S!"OT!YT_W_"SI"S[TI[X!"S_"U][`!"IUT!OI[_
,&,""6.&"$"W-)-,*V+-$"O57'-($"):$"V"3/+*&"".#"3+$(&,,$B"/"'&-"$+?l)-(/"'
+&,&+2/".#"status"3/+*-(.'/+B"3&+#-*-)%$"$7*&+"-)0$+#/9Q&,",$7+&"$,"(/,$,")$,"
6./-,".#/"NO8"0$-"/3+&,&)*/%/"&"&)*:$"-*-+",./"$3-)-:$EJA
U#/"2&;" ($)" $," '&?-*-#/%$,"3/+/" /3+&,&)*/+" .#"6.&,*-$)/#&)*$B"
($)2V#"&,*.%/+"$,"M.@;&,"6.&" 3$%"+&(&71D'$,A"8$#"status"%&"+&(.+,$"%$"M.+-,D
%-(-$)/%$"#&%-/%$"3&'$"M.-;B"/"NO8"):$"3$%&",&+"/3+&,&)*/%/"%-+&*/#&)*&"3&+/)D
*&"$"8$),&'<$"8$),*-*.(-$)/'A"O$+"%&*&+#-)/9:$"%/"L&-"!+?l)-(/"%&"JKKFB"/"NO8"
3$%&",&+"3+$3$,*/"3&+/)*&"*$%/,"/,"-),*l)(-/,"%&"M.+-,%-9:$"%&"$+%"/%#-)-,*+/D
WLYDTXHpFRPSHWrQFLDGR&RQVHOKRGH(VWDGRRXMXGLFLDOTXHFRPSHWHj&RUWH
%&"8/,,/9:$A"L$?$B"3$%&",&+"3+$3$,*/""3+-#&-+/"-),*l)(-/B"/,,-#"($#$"*/#7V#"
"?+/."%&"/3&'/9:$B")$"X+-7.)/'"_%#-)-,*+/*-2$"$.")/"8$+*&"%&"_3&'/9:$A
I2-%&)*&)*&B"/" NO8"3$%&" ,&+"/3+&,&)*/%/" %-+&*/#&)*&"3&+/)*&"$" 8$)D
,&' I,*/%$"&"/" 8$+*&"%&" 8/,,/9:$B"%/" #&,#/"#/)&-+/"($#$" $($++&")$,"
WULEXQDLV´QDQFHLURVEdB")$,"*+-7.)/-,"M.%-(-P+-$,"&"/%#-)-,*+/*-2$,"&,3&(-/'-;/%$,Ec"
&"/-)%/")$,"*+-7.)/-,"#-'-*/+&,"&"3$'@*-($,"($#$"/"8$+*&"%&"n.,*-9/"%/"T&357'-(/EGA
!"8$),&''&?-,'/*-2/,"="/6.&D
'/,"6.&"3$%" ,&+"$7M&*$"%&" ($)*+$'&")$"l#7-*$" %/"NO8"=" $,"*&4*$,"6.&" *&D
)#" ,-%$" /%$*/%$," 3$+" /'?.#/" /.*$+-%/%&" %&*&)*$+/" %&" 3$%&+" '&?-,'/*-2$A"
S&,*/"0$+#/B",:$"+&3+&,&)*/%/,"&,,&)(-/'#&)*&"3$+".#"%-3'$#/")$+#/*-2$"6.&"
*&)",-%$"2$*/%$"3&'$"O/+'/#&)*$B" )$"6./'"&,*:$"-)('.@%/,"'&-,"$+%-)P+-/,B" '&-,"
RUJkQLFDVRXGHFUHWRVUDWL´FDGRVSHOR3DUODPHQWRE^A
_$"*+/*/+"%/,"'&-,"$+?l)-(/,"($)2V#"+&,,/'2/+"6.&"&,*/,"'&-,"0$+/#"$7+-?/D
*$+-/#&)*&",.7#&*-%/,"/$" &4/#&"%&"($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&"%$" 8$),&'
*.(-$)/'"/)*&,"%&",./"3+$#.'?/9:$A"S-/)*&" %-,,$B"/"/3+&,&)*/9:$"%&".#/"NO8"
($)*+/"/,"+&0&+-%/," '&-,",.3Q&"/" )&(&,,-%/%&"%&",&" %$),*+/+"*&+"2-%$B" "
FRQIRUPLGDGHFRPDVFRQGLo}HVGH´OWUDJHPDQDOLVDGDVXPDPXGDQoDGHFLUD
FXQVWkQFLDVGHGLUHLWRRXGHIDWRTXHMXVWL´TXHRUHH[DPHSHOR&RQVHOKR&RQVD
*-*.(-$)/'"%/"%-,3$,-9:$"'&?-,'/*-2/"$+?l)-(/A
(PUHODomRjVOHLVGHUDWL´FDomRGHWUDWDGRVLQWHUQDFLRQDLVFDEHD´UPDUTXH
&,*/,"0$+/#"&4('.@%/,"%$"l#7-*$"%&"/3'-(/9:$"%/"NO8A"[,*$"3$+6.&"*/-,"'&-,"$+%-)PD
+-/,"*1#"($#$"5)-($"$7M&*$"/,,&?.+/+"/"-),&+9:$")$"S-+&-*$"0+/)(1,"%&"(&+*/,"($)D
EJ" [%AB"JKEJB"3AEcA
Ed" X+-7.)/'"%&"8$)*/,B"(0B"8$),&'
Ec" 8$),&'
EG" 8$+*&"%&"n.,*-9/"%/"T&357'-(/B"S&(-,:$"%&"EF"&"/7+-'"%&"JKEKB"8+'&,"O/,6./A"
E^" 4XHQWHQGRQSDUGLVSRVLWLRQOpJLVODWLYHt€"['",•/?-*"%•.)"*&4*&"/%$3*V"3/+"'•/.*$+-*V" %V*&D
)/)*"'&"3$.2$-+"'V?-,'/*-0A"8•&,*"%$)("&,,&)*-&''&)*".)"*&4*&"2$*V"3/+"'&"O/+'&)*"h'$-B"'$-"
RUJDQLTXHRXRUGRQQDQFHUDWL´pHSDUOH3DUOHPHQW/DTXHVWLRQSULRULWDLUHGHFRQVWLWXWLRQ
)/'-*VA"SV($.2+-+"'/"NO8A
“12 questions pour commencer”, 3A"KE. S-,3$)@2&'"k"
)&'A0+u($),&-'D($),*-*.*-$))&'u+$$*u7/)wu3%0u($),&-'D($),*-*.*-$))&'DcbEKbA3%0
"_"TIL_x`!"I]XTI"U][`!"IUT!OI[_"I"_"NUI\X `!"OT[!T[XyT[_""EbE"
"SI"8!]\X[XU8[!]_L[S_SI"S!"S[TI[X!"CT_]8z\
2&)9Q&,"-)*&+)/(-$)/-,A"8$),&6.&)*&)*&B"&)*&)%&.D,&"6.&" ($)*+$'/+"/"($),*-D
WXFLRQDOLGDGHGHVWDVOHLVVLJQL´FDULDQDSUiWLFDUHH[DPLQDURWH[WRGRWUDWDGREbA
I#",&"*+/*/)%$"%/,")$+#/," ($),*-*.(-$)/-,"6.&"3$%",&+"-)2$(/%/," "
,&%&" %&" NO8B" V" -#3$+*/)*&" /*&)*/+" 3/+/" /" &4-,*1)(-/" %$" m'$($" %&" 8$),*-*.D
(-$)/'-%/%&EHB"($)M.)*$"%&")$+#/,"0$+#/'#&)*&"($),*-*.(-$)/-,"($#3$,*$"3&'/"
S&('/+/9:$"%$,"S-+&-*$,"%$"j$#" &"%$"8-%/%:$"%&"EbHFB" 3&'$"O+&l#7.'$"%/"
8$),*-*.-9:$"%&"EFc^B" 3&'$,"O+-)(@3-$,"C.)%/#&)*/-,"T&($) 3&'/,"L&-,"
%/"T&357'-(/EFB"&"/#3'-/%$"3&'/"8/+*/"%$"W&-$"_#7-&)*&"%&"JKKcB")$+#/,"&,*/,"
6.&"/%6.-+-/#"status"($),*-*.(-$)/'"/$",&+"($),/?+/%/,"3&'$" O+&l#7.'$"%/"
8$),*-*.-9:$"%&"EFGHA
L$?$B"):$" /3&)/," $" *&4*$" %/" 8$),*-*.-9:$" %/" T&357'-(/" C+/)(&,/" ,&+2&"
($#$"3/+l#&*+$" 3/+/" /"/3+&,&)*/9:$" %&".#/" NO8B" #/,"*/#7V#" /,")$+#/,"
($)*-%/,")$," %-3'$#/,",.3+/(-*/%$,B" %&,%&" 6.&"*+/*B" V"('/+$B" %&"%-+&-*$," &"
'-7&+%/%&,"($),*-*.(-$)/-,A
U#/"2&;" +&(&7-%$" 3$+" .#" M.-;" $+%-)P+-$B" $" +&6.&+-#&)*$" %&" NO8" 3/,,/"
SRUXPSURFHVVRGH´OWUDJHPQRVWULEXQDLVLQIHULRUHVTXHGHYHDWHQGHUDWUrV
(+-*V+-$,"&,*/7&'&(-%$,"3&'$"/+*-?$"Jd"%/"L&-"!+?l)-(/"%&"JKKFk
/i"_" %-,3$,-9:$" '&?-,'/*-2/" ($)*&,*/%/" 3+&(-,/" ,&+" /3'-(P2&'" /$" '-*@?-$" $."
3+$(&,,$B"$."($),*-*.-+"$"0.)%/#&)*$"%/"6.&,*:$"6.&"&,*P",&)%$"%-,(.*-%/R
7i"_"%-,3$,-9:$"'&?-,'/*-2/"(+-*-(/%/"):$"3$%&"MP"*&+",-%$"%&('/+/%/"($)0$+D
#&"/"8$),*-*.-9:$"3&'$"8$),&'8$),*-*.(-$)/'B",/'2$",&"*-2&+"2-%$"#.%/)9/"
%&"(-+(.),*l)(-/,JKBJER
Eb" [%AB"JKEJB"3A"dKA
EH"e!"Bloc de constitutionnalité"-)('.-"$"O+&l#7.'$"%/"8$),*-*.-9:$"%&"EFc^B"(/+*/"($),*-*.(-$)/'"
SURJUHVVLVWDHODERUDGDORJRDSyVR´PGD*XHUUD0XQGLDOHTXHFRQWpPRHVVHQFLDOGRV
%-+&-*$,"0.)%/#&)*/-,"3&(-/'#&)*&"$,"%&")/*.+&;/",$(-/'R"3$+",./"
YH]R3UHkPEXORGHID]UHPLVVmRj'HFODUDomR8QLYHUVDOGRV'LUHLWRVGR+RPHPHGR
8-%/%:$"%&"EbHFB"/$,"eO+-)(@3-$,"C.)%/#&)*/-,"+&($) T&357'-(/gB"-,*$"
pRHOHQFRGHSULQFtSLRVFRQWLGRVQDVOHLVOLEHUDLVYRWDGDVHQWUHR´PGR6HJXQGR,PSpULR
HD6HJXQGD*XHUUDHSRU´P DXPDFDWHJRULDQRUPDWLYDDSDUHQWHPHQWHREVFXUD
PDVTXHHPUHDOLGDGHSRVVLELOLWDXPDFRQVWDQWHUHQRYDomRHDEHUWXUDjHYROXomRGRSHQVDD
#&)*$B"$,"(#/%$,"e3+-)(@3-$,"3$'@*-($,B"&($)|#-($,"&",$(-/-,"3/+*-(.'/+#&)*&")&(&,,P+-$,"
/$")$,,$" *$gAg"hm_Tm!\_B" n$/6.-#A"I2$'.9:$" %$"($)*+$'&" %&" ($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&"%&"
*-3$"0+/)(1,A"[)A"T&2-,*/"%&"[)0$+#/9:$"L&?-,'/*-2/A"/A"cK")A"EGH"/7+AuM.)A"m+/,@'-/k"JKKdA"3A"EJJiA
EF" mUTSI_UB"Y&$+?&,A"j_W!]B"C+/)(-,A"XT!OITB"W-(=(3$")0>+&;40:&3#4;4$4;&33"))"A"JGf"
&%AB"O/+-,k"L-7+/-+-&"YV)V+/'&"%&"S+$-*"&*"%&"n.+-,3+.%&)(&B"EFFbB"3A"bKKA
JK" "S&(-,:$"){"JKEKDEcuJJ"NO8"%&"dK"%&"M.'
JE 'H´QLomRHVWDEHOHFLGDSHOR&RQVHOKR&RQVWLWXFLRQDOª$PXGDQoDGHFLUFXQVWkQFLDVGHGLD
+&-*$0&,*P"+&'/(-$)/%/B"3$+"&4'$B" /".#/"+&2-,:$"%/" 8$),*-*.-9:$A"!"8$),&'
(-$)/'"):$"3$%&+-/",&"3+$).)(-/+" /)*&,"6.&"/"+&2-,:$"0$,,&"/%$*/%/A" _"3/+*-+"%&,*/"/'*&+/D
9:$")$"*&4*$"($),*-*.(-$)/'" .#/"NO8"3$%&+P",&+"/3+&,&)*/%/" ($)*+/".#/"%-,3$,-9:$"6.&"
MP"*&)",-%$" %&('/+/%/"($)0$+#&"/" 8$),*-*.-9:$A"_"#.%/)9/" %&"(-+(.),*l)(-/,"%&" 0/*$"V"
.#"3$.($"#/-,"($#3'-(/%/" %&",&"($#3+&&)%&+",&?.)%$" $,"M.+-,*/,"0+/)(&,&,A"]$" l#7-*$"
%/"NO8"$"8$),&' %&"#/)&-+/"(/%/"2&;"#/-,"0+&6.&)*&"
6./)%$"*+/*/"%&"3+-,:$" 3+&2&)*-2/B"3/+/"(/+/(*&+-;/+".#/" &0&*-2/"#.%/)9/"%&"(-+(.),*l)D
FLDVGHIDWRH DVVLPMXVWL´FDURUHH[DPHGH XPDGLVSRVLomROHJLVODWLYDFRQWHVWDGDTXH QR
FDVRFRQFUHWRIRLGHFODUDGDFRQWUiULDj&RQVWLWXLomR«7UDGXomROLYUHGRDXWRU
EbJ"TIZ[\X_"S!"OT!YT_W_"SI"S[TI[X!"S_"U][`!"IUT!OI[_
(i"_"6.&,*:$"):$"3$%&",&+"%&,3+$2-%/"%&"(/+P*&+",V+-$A
6RPHQWHDSyVHVWHSURFHVVRRTXHVWLRQDPHQWRp´QDOPHQWHUHFHELGRSHOR
8$),&'#V+-*$"&"%&(-%-+P",&"/"%-,3$,-9:$"'&?-,'/D
*-2/"(.M/"($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&"&,*P",&)%$"($)*&,*/%/"VB"$."):$B" ($)0$+#&"/"8$),D
WLWXLomR1HVWHVHQWLGRFDEH D´UPDUTXH RV HIHLWRVGDVGHFLV}HV GR&RQVHOKR
8$),*-*.(-$)/'",:$"erga omnes, $.",&M/B 2/'"3/+/"*$%$,B"):$"/%#-*-)%$"+&(.+,$A
1RMiFLWDGR DUWLJR GD&RQVWLWXLomRYHUL´FDVH TXHRVHIHLWRV GHXPD
%&(-,:$"",&%&"%&"NO8"*"($#$"($),&6.1)(-/"/"+&2$?/9:$"%/"'&-" ($),-%&D
+/%/"):$" ($)0$+#&" /"8$),*-*.-9:$B" (/7&)%$" /$"8$),&' 8$),*-*.(-$)/'B"3$+"
.#/"%&(-,:$",$7&+/)/B"+&2$?PD'/"-#&%-/*/#&)*&"$."%&"0$+#/"%-0&+-%/A"!"/+*-?$"
^J"&,*/7&'&(&." */#7V#" ,&+"$" 8$),&' >+?:$" +&,3$),P2&'"3$+" %&*&+#-)/+"
/,"($)%-9Q&,"&"$,"'-#-*&,"%$,"&0&-*$,"3+$%.;-%$,"3&'/"+&2$?/9:$"%/"%-,3$,-9:$"
OHJLVODWLYDFRQWHVWDGDHPVHGHGH43&2TXHVLJQL´FDGL]HUTXHD&RQVWLWXLomR
/*+-7.-."/$"8$),&'
&0&-*$,g"%&",./"%&(-,:$B"6.&"-#3'-(/"%&(-%-+" $,"&0&-*$,"($)(+&*$,"6.&"/"#&,#/"
GHYHSURGX]LUGHDFRUGRFRPDVHVSHFL´FLGDGHVGRFDVR
!"3$%&+"%&"#$%.'/9:$"V"-#3$+*/)*&"($),-%&+/)%$"6.&",&.,"3+-)(-3/-,"$7D
M&*-2$," ,:$" e3+&&)(
EHQH´FLDUGDLQFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDGH«JJB"3/+/"6.&"/,,-#"$"M.-;"($),*-*.(-$)/'" ):$"
&4&+9/"$"3/3&'"-)%&2-%$"%&" e6./,&"'&?-,'/%$+g"($#"$"-)*.-*$"%&" +&,$'2&+"*$%/,"
/,",-*./9Q&,"+&'/(-$)/%/,"/$" $7M&*$"%/"'&-"+&2$?/%/B"" 6.&"3$%&+-/"&)2$'2&+"
,&.,"3+>3+-$,"-)*&+&,,&,A
m.,(/+D,&DP"/"3/+*-+"%&"/?$+/"/3+&,&)*/+"$"($)*+$'&"%&"($)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&"
&"&,*/7&'&(&+".#/" 3$,,@2&'"+&'/9:$"&)*+&"/" NO8"&"$" ($)*+$'&"%&"'&-,"+&/'-;/%$"
3&'$,"M.@;&,"$+%-)P+-$,")$"6.&"*/)?&"/$"%-+&-*$"&.+$3&.A
9?9010@0-&34+&)"05"0-&3*"3-;&3();5(5"03&0A%B;4&05(0$3;7&0"$+&C";(0"0(0
TXHVWmRSULRULWiULDGHFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDGH
I#"*&+#$," M.+@%-($,B"$" ($)*+$'&"%&"($)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&" 3$,,.-"&4/*/D
#&)*&"/"#&,#/")/*.+&;/"%$"($)*+$'&"%&"($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&"3&'/"2-/"
%&"&4(&9:$A" _" +/;:$" 3/+/" .#" M.-;" 0+/)(1," %&,(/+*/+" /" /3'-(/9:$" %&"
XPDOHL FRQWUiULD jV SUHYLV}HV GH XP WUDWDGR PHVPR DQWHV GH VXD
""Z&+,:$"$+-?-)/'k"Le changement de circonstances de droit concerne par exemple une ré*
vision de la Constitution. Le Conseil constitutionnel n’ayant pu se prononcer avant que la ré*
YLVLRQQHVRLWDGRSWpHXQH43&SRXUUDrWUHIRUPpHFRQWUHODGLVSRVLWLRQOpJLVODWLYHSRXUWDQW
GHFODUpHFRQIRUPH/HFKDQJHPHQWGHFLUFRQVWDQFHVGHIDLWHVWSOXVGLI´FLOHjDSSUpKHQGHU
SRXUOHVMXULVWHV'DQVODFDGUHGHOD43&OH&RQVHLOFRQVWLWXWLRQQHOUHWLHQWOHUHFRXUVGH
plus en plus frequent à la garde à vue pour caracteriser un changement de circonstances de
IDLWHWDLQVLMXVWL´HU OHUpH[DPHQGHOD GLVSRVLWLRQOHJLVODWLYHFRQWHVWpHTXLHQ OHVSqFHHVW
declare contraire à la Constitution. S-,3$)@2&'"k"[%AB"JKEJB"33A"^JD^dA
JJ" [%AB"JKEJB"3A"EEKA
"_"TIL_x`!"I]XTI"U][`!"IUT!OI[_"I"_"NUI\X `!"OT[!T[XyT[_""Ebd"
"SI"8!]\X[XU8[!]_L[S_SI"S!"S[TI[X!"CT_]8z\
-)*&+)/'-;/9:$B"V"&4/*/#&)*&"/"#&,#/".*-'-;/%/")$"+/(-$(@)-$"%$"Chief
Justice"W/+,''""EHKd")$"0/#$,$"(/,$"W/+7.+~"ZA,"W/%-,$)A
I#"*&+#$," 3+P*-($,B"$," %$-,"*-3$," %&"($)*+$'&" ,:$"-%1)*-($," )$"
,&."l#7-*$" %&"/*./9:$A" 8$#"&0&-*$B" &4(&*$B"*/'2&;B" )/"P+&/" ,$(-/'B"/"
8$)2&)9:$"I.+$3&-/"%$,"S-+&-*$,"j.#/)$,"/'(/)9/"&",.3&+/"$"(/*P'$D
?$"%&"%-+&-*$,"0.)%/#&)*/-,"($),/?+/%$,")/"C+/)9/"3&'/"8$),*-*.-9:$"
%&"EFGHB"&" ,&."O+&l#7.'$B"/" S&('/+/9:$"%&"S-+&-*$,"%$" j$#"&"%$"
8-%/%:$"%&" EbHFB"$" O+&l#7.'$"%/" 8$),*-*.-9:$"%&" EFc^"&" O+-)(@3-$,"
C.)%/#&)*/-,"T&($)
$PERVRVWLSRVGHFRQWUROHWrP´QDOPHQWHRPHVPR HIHLWRSUiWLFR
I#7$+/"/," %&(-,Q&,"" *&+#$,"%&"($)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&" ):$"3$,,./#"
/"/.*$+-%/%&" +&'/*-2/"%$"*+l),-*$" "M.'?/%$B"&,*/7&'&(&+/#" .#/"M.D
+-,3+.%1)(-/"6.&"%&2&",&+",&?.-%/"&B")/"3+P*-(/B",:$"+&,3$),P2&-,"3$+"
XPDIDVWDPHQWR GHOHLV FRQVLGHUDGDVFRQWUiULDV j&RQYHQomR (XURD
3&-/"%$,"S-+&-*$,"j.#/)$,JdA
]/"C+/)9/B" $" ($)*+$'&"%&" ($)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&" ="#&(/)-,#$" 3$+"#&-$" %$"
6./'"V"+&/'-;/%$"$"($)*+$'&"%/,"'&-,"&"%$,"+&?.'/#&)*$,"+&'/(-$)/%$," /$,"($#D
3+$#-,,$,"-)*&+)/(-$)/-,"%/"U)-:$"I.+$3&-/"="V"%&"($#3&*1)(-/"&4('.,-2/"%$,"
*+-7.)/-,"M.%-(-P+-$,"&"/%#-)-,*+/*-2$,JcA
(VWHSRVLFLRQDPHQWRIRL HVWDEHOHFLGRSRUPHLRGD GHFLVmRUHODWLYDj ª/HL
Z&-'gJG"%&"EG"%&"M/)&-+$"%&"EFbGB"6./)%$"$"8$),&' %&(-%-."6.&"
Jd" SI"L_W!XjIB"!'-2-&+"S.* ($),*-*.*-$)D
)/'-*V"&)"C+/)(&A"Z-,-*&"/."X+-7.)/'"8$),*-*.*-$))&'"I,3/?)$'B"W/%+-%B"JDc"%&"_7+-'"%&"JKKFA"
3A"KdA" X+/%.9:$"'-2+&"%$" /.*$+A"Z&+,:$" $+-?-)/': “Sur le plan juridique, le contrôle de con*
ventionnalité est exactement de même nature qu’un contrôle de constitutionnalité par voie
d’exception. Le raisonnementtenu par un juge français pour écarter l’application d’une loi
contraire auxstipulations d’un traité, même antérieur, est exactement le même que leraison*
QHPHQWWHQXSDUOH&KLHI-XVWLFH0DUVKDOOHQGDQVODUUrW0DUEXU\FRQWUH0DGLVRQ
Sur le plan pratique, les deux types de contrôle ont une portée identique. En effet, sauf
peut*être en matière sociale, la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme englobe et
même dépasse le catalogue des droits fondamentaux tel qu’il résulte, en France, de la Cons*
WLWXWLRQGHHWGHVRQ3UpDPEXOHGHOD'pFODUDWLRQGHVGURLWVGHOKRPPHHWGXFLWR\HQ
GHGX3UpDPEXOHGHOD&RQVWLWXWLRQGHHWGHVSULQFLSHVIRQGDPHQWDX[UHFRQQXV
par les lois de la république auxquels il renvoie.
/HVGHX[W\SHVGHFRQWU{OHRQWHQ´QOHVPrPHVHIIHWVSUDWLTXHV0rPHVLOHVGpFLVLRQV
rendues en matière de conventionnalité n’ont que l’autorité relative de la chose jugée, elles
font jurisprudence et aboutissent, en pratique, à une paralysie des lois jugées contraires à
la Convention européenne des droits de l’homme. L’expérience des pays qui, comme les
eWDWV8QLVFRQQDLVVHQW XQFRQWU{OHGH FRQVWLWXWLRQQDOLWpSDU YRLHGH[FHSWLRQ HVWOj SRXU
FRQ´UPHUOHVHIIHWVSXLVVDQWVGXQWHOFRQWUROH«
Jc" S&(-,:$"){"JKEKDcuEb"NO8B"JJ"%&"M.'
JG" Loi n°75*17 du 17 janvier 1975 DITE SIMONE VEIL RELATIVE A L’INTERRUPTION VOLON*
7$,5('(*5266(66(,9*"_" eL&-"Z&-'gB"6.&"/.*$+-;/2/"/"-)*&++.39:$" 2$'.)*P+-/"%/"?+/D
2-%&;B"0$-"/%$*/%/"3$+".#"3&+@$%$" %&"(-)($"/)$,"&"0$-"+&2$?/%/" 3&'/"'&-"/RLQGX
31 décembre 1979 relative à l’interruption volontaire de la grossesse./S-,3$)@2&'"k/
ZZZOHJLIUDQFHJRXYIUDI´FK7H[WHGR"FLG7H[WH -25)7(;7
Ebc"TIZ[\X_"S!"OT!YT_W_"SI"S[TI[X!"S_"U][`!"IUT!OI[_
$"&4/#&"%&"($#3/*-7-'-%/%&"%/,"'&-,"0+/)(&,/,"($#" /,"($)2&)9Q&,"-)*&+)/(-$D
)/-,"&" &.+$3&-/,"):$"&+/" %&",./"($#3&*1)(-/J^A" 8$#"7/,&" )&,*&"&)*&)%-#&)D
WRIRLGH´QLGR TXHRFRQWUROH GHFRQYHQFLRQDOLGDGHSRGHULD VHUH[HUFLGR SRU
6./'6.&+"M.-;"="M.%-(-P+-$"$."/%#-)-,*+/*-2$"="*$%/"2&;"6.&"3+$2$(/%$"3$+".#"
M.+-,%-(-$)/%$A
_"%&(-,:$" %&"):$" +&/'-;/+"$" ($)*+$'&"%&" ($)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&"%/," '&-,"*&2&"
($#$"($),&6.1)(-/")/*.+/'".#"/0/,*/#&)*$"&)*+&"$"8$),&'&"
/"8$+*&"I.+$3&-/"%&"S-+&-*$,"j.#/)$,A"X/'"+&M&-9:$"%$"8$),&'
+&,.'*$."".#/"/.,1)(-/"%&"($)&4:$"&)*+&"$,"M.@;&,"%/,"%./,"($+*&,B"$+/"
HVWDIDOWDGHFRQH[mRQmRVLJQL´TXHTXHDV GXDVLQVWLWXLo}HVQXQFDWHQKDPVH
FRPXQLFDGReSRVVtYHOD´UPDUTXHDSHVDUGRkPELWRGHDWXDomRGLVWLQWRWDQD
*$"$"8$),&' 8$+*&"%&,&)2$'2&+/#".#/"M.+-,3+.%1)(-/"%&"3+$*&9:$"
%&"%-+&-*$,"&"'-7&+%/%&,"&4*+/#&)*&"($)2&+?&)*&,JbA
!" &)*&)%-#&)*$" ($),$'-%/%$" 3&'$" 8$),&'
DSOLFDjH[LJrQFLDFRQVWLWXFLRQDOGHWUDQVSRVLomR GDV'LUHWLYDVGD8QLmR(XURD
3&-/"6.&"):$",&"&)6./%+/#")/,"'-7&+%/%&,"&"%-+&-*$,"?/+/)*-%$,"3&'/"8$),*-*.-D
9:$JHA"L$?$B"/"($#3/*-7-'-%/%&"%/,"%-+&*-2/,"*/#7V#"%&2&",&+"&4/#-)/%/"3&'$,"
*+-7.)/-,"/%#-)-,*+/*-2$,"&"M.%-(-P+-$,A
,PSRUWDQWHVDOLHQWDUTXHR&RQVHOKR &RQVWLWXFLRQDOFRQ´UPRXVHXHQWHQD
%-#&)*$"=",$7+&"):$"3$,,.-+"($#3&*1)(-/"3/+/"M.'?/+"/"($)0$+#-%/%&"%/,"'&-,"
0+/)(&,/,"($#" $"%-+&-*$" &.+$3&."=" /$"%&('/+/+" 6.&"$" /+*-?$"GG" %/"8$),*-*.-D
9:$JFpXPDUHJUDGHFRQµLWRGHQRUPDVQRVLVWHPDPRQLVWDIUDQFrVFDEHQGR
SRUWDQWRDXPMXL]HQFDUUHJDGRGDDSOLFDomRGDOHLDSOLFDU DUHJUDGHFRQµLWR
6.&"+&M&-*/"/"'&?-,'/9:$")/(-$)/'"6./)%$"&'/"V"($)*+P+-/"/".#"($#3+$#-,,$"&.D
+$3&."$." -)*&+)/(-$)/'"" 2-?$+A"O/+/"$" 8$),&' /"
-#3$,*/"3&'$"/+*-?$"GG"):$"($),*-*.-B"%&,*&"#$%$B".#/"+&?+/"%&"2/'-%/%&"($),D
*-*.(-$)/'"%/,"'&-,dKA
]$"&)*/)*$B",&"0/;")&(&,,P+-$"/3$)*/+"6.&"($#"/"&2$'.9:$"M.+-,3+.%&)(-/'"
%$"+&,3&-*$"/$,"/($+%$,"($#.)-*P+-$,"="&"&,3&(-/'#&)*&"/"3/+*-+"%&"JKEK"($#"
J^" "8$),&'
Jb" YU[LL_UWIB"W/+(A" N.&,*-$)" O+-$+-*/-+&" S&" 8$),*-*.*-$))/'-*V" I*" 8$)2&)*-$)" I.+$3V&))&"
S&,"S+$-*,"S&"Lo
2&)*-$)"&.+$3V&))&"%&,"%+$-*,"%&"'o0S-,3$)@2&'"k"‚
vvvA($),&-'D($),*-*.*-$))&'A0+u($),&-'D($),*-*.*-$))&'u+$$*u7/)wu3%0u($),&-'D($),*-*.*-$D
))&'DFFKG^A3%0ƒ
JH" S&(-,:$"){"JKEKD^KG"S&(-,:$"%&"8$)0$+#-%/%&"%&"EJ"%&"#/-$"%&"JKEKA
JF" _+*-?$"GG"%/"8$),*-*.-9:$"%/"T&357'-(/"C+/)(&,/k
2VWUDWDGRV RX DFRUGRV UHJXODUPHQWH UDWL´FDGRV RX DSURYDGRV WrP D SDUWLU GD VXD
SXEOLFDomRDXWRULGDGHVXSHULRUjGDVOHLVVXMHLWRSDUDFDGDDFRUGRRXWUDWDGRjVXDDSOLD
(/9:$"3&'/"$.*+/"3/+*&A"
dK" S-,3$)@2&'"k"
(.#&)*/*-$)u($)*+-7.*-$),D&*D%-,($.+,uJKEEu($)*+$'&D%&D($),*-*.*-$))/'-*&D&*D%+$-*D%&D'D
D.)-$)D&.+$3&&))&AEdGdGcA
"_"TIL_x`!"I]XTI"U][`!"IUT!OI[_"I"_"NUI\X `!"OT[!T[XyT[_""EbG"
"SI"8!]\X[XU8[!]_L[S_SI"S!"S[TI[X!"CT_]8z\
/"&)*+/%/""2-?$+"%/"NO8"="$,"($)*+$'&,"%&"($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&"&"%&"($)2&)D
(-$)/'-%/%&"3/+&(",&"/3+$4-#/+"&",&"#-,*.+/+dEA
I,*/"/3+$4-#/9:$" ,&" %&." 3&'$" 0/*$" %&" /" NO8" ,&+" ?&+/%/" %&)*+$" %&" .#"
3+$(&,,$B" &" .#/" 2&;" /3+&,&)*/%/" /$" M.-;" ($#3&*&)*&" %$" 3+$(&,,$" " *&'/B"
GHYHSDVVDUSRUXPSURFHGLPHQWRGH´OWUDJHPDWpVHUUHFHELGDSHOR&RQVHOKR
8$),*-*.(-$)/'A"_3&)/,"$"8$),&'/")$+#/"
%&('/+/%/"-)($),*-*.(-$)/'"%$"$+%&)/#&)*$"M.+@%-($"0+/)(1,dJA
_"NO8B"3$+",&+".#"#&(/)-,#$"($#3'&*/#&)*&")$2$"&"%-,*-)*$"%$"($)*+$'&"
%&"($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&" &4('.,-2/#&)*&"3+&2&)*-2$" &4-,*&)*&"/*V" JKEKB"+&)$2/"
3+$0.)%/#&)*&"/"0$+#/" %&"/3'-(/9:$"%/" 8$)2&)9:$"I.+$3&-/"%&" S-+&-*$,"j.D
#/)$,""+&'/9:$" /$"8$),&' &,3&(-/'#&)*&")$"6.&" %-;"+&,D
SHLWRjVIRUPDOLGDGHVGHVHXSURFHGLPHQWRMiTXHGHYHVHUDSUHVHQWDGDFRPR
XPREMHWRHVFULWRGLVWLQWRHPRWLYDGR(DLQGDQRTXHVHUHIHUHjLQRYDomRGRV
&0&-*$,"+&2$?/*>+-$,"%&" .#/"%&(-,:$"%$"8$),&' ",&%&"%&" NO8B"2-,*$"6.&"
,:$"erga omnes.
_$"#&,#$"*$B" /,"#.%/)9/,"*+/;-%/," 3&'/"NO8"):$"0$+/#" 3'&)/#&)D
WH DFHLWDV VREUHWXGR QR TXH VH UHIHUH j JUDQGH SUR[LPLGDGH DWXDO HQWUH RV
%-+&-*$,"&"'-7&+%/%&,"3+$*&?-%$,"3&'/"&,0&+/" %&"/*./9:$"%$"($)*+$'&"%&"($),*-D
*.(-$)/'-%/%&"&"$"($)*+$'&"%&" ($)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&A"8$#"7/,&")&,*&"/+?.#&)*$B"
RSRVLWRUHVGD43&D´UPDUDPLQFOXVLYHTXHDUHIRUPDFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHUDLQ~WLO
,QHYLWDYHOPHQWHR FDUiWHU SULRULWiULR GD 43& HP UHODomR jV GHPDLV GHD
#/)%/,"3+$(&,,./-," ?&+$."#.-*$," 6.&,*-$)/#&)*$,"/" +&,3&-*$" %/"(+-/9:$" %&"
.#"e+-,($"%&"($)*+/%-9:$g" &)*+&"/"3+-$+-%/%&"%&" &4/#&"%/"NO8"&" $"%-+&-*$"%/"
U)-:$"I.+$3&-/A
(VWH«UHFHLR«HQFRQWUDVXDSULQFLSDO MXVWL´FDWLYD )/"%&(-,:$"\-##&)*'ddB"
3$+"#&-$"%/"6./'"$"M.-;"($#.)-*P+-$"-#3|,"/$"M.-;")/(-$)/'"$"%&2&+"%&"/3'-(/+")/"
@)*&?+/"&" %&"-#&%-/*$"$" %-+&-*$"%/"U)-:$" I.+$3&-/B"&B",&" )&(&,,P+-$B"%&,(/+*/+"
*$%/,"/,"+&?+/,"%&"%-+&-*$")/(-$)/'A
eRªULVFRGHFRQWUDGLomR«TXHH[SOLFDDH[LVWrQFLDGHXPDSULPHLUDYHU,
#7&05(0D";0@+EA3;-(0 5"09FFGB"6.&"/$"*+/*/+" %$"(/+P*&+"3+-$+-*P+-$"%/"6.&,*:$"
%&" ($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&" 2-/" &,*/7&'&(-%$" .#" +&?+/#&)*$" 3/+*-(.'/+" 3/+/" $"
%-+&-*$"($#.)-*P+-$A"O$+"($)*/"%$"+&(&-$"&4-,*&)*&""+&'/9:$"/"&,*&"e+-,($gB"$"
dE" m_8jITXB"_.%+&~A" 8$)*+$'&"S&"8$),*-*.*-$))/'-*V" &*"8$)*+$'&" S&"8$)2&)*-$))/'-*Vk" Z&+,"
L/"O+-#/.*V"_7,$'.&"S."S+$-*"8$##.)/.*/-+&€"S-,3$)@2&'"k"
IU5HVVRXUFHV'RFXPHQWV(WXGLDQWV0HPRLUHV&\EHUGRFV0)(EDFKHUWBDSGI
EDFKHUWBDSGI
dJ" YU[LL_UWIB" W/+(A" N.&,*-$)" O+-$+-*/-+&" S&" 8$),*-*.*-$))/'-*V" I*" 8$)2&)*-$)" I.+$3V&)D
)&"S&," S+$-*," S&" Lo
k"8$)2&)*-$)" &.+$3V&))&"%&," %+$-*,"%&" 'o n.' JKEEB"3A" KdA0S-,3$)@2&'"k"
($),*-*.*-$)")&'DFFKG^A3%0A
dd"
Eb^"TIZ[\X_"S!"OT!YT_W_"SI"S[TI[X!"S_"U][`!"IUT!OI[_
WH[WR´QDOQmRID]GLVWLQomRHQWUHRVFRPSURPLVVRVLQWHUQDFLRQDLVHHXURSHXV
%/"C+/)9/A
S&"0/*$B" $"%&7/*&" /(&+(/"%$"(/+P*&+" 3+-$+-*P+-$"%/" NO8"&" ,./"($#3/*-7-D
'-%/%&" ($#" $" ($)*+$'&" %&" ($)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&" ,&" %&." 3$+" .#/" %&(-,:$" %&" E^"
%&"/7+-'"%&" JKEKdcA"_"8$+*&"%&" 8/,,/9:$",&"#/)-0&,*$." )$",&)*-%$"%&"+&,$'2&+"
DFRQWURYpUVLD EDVHDGDQXPDTXHVWmR SUHMXGLFLDOUHODWLYD jFRQIRUPLGDGHGR
&4/#&"3+-$+-*P+-$"%/"NO8"-#3$,*$"3&'/"L&-"!+?l)-(/"%&"JKKF""+&'/9:$"/"*+/D
*/%$,"($#.)-*P+-$,A"]$"&)*/)*$B"V")&(&,,P+-$" 3$)%&+/+"6.&"$"-)*&+&,,&"2&'/%$"
%/"8$+*&"%&"8/,,/9:$" )&,*&"#V+-*$"&+/"(+-*-(P2&'B" 3$-,",&"+&'/(-$)/2/"/$"$7M&D
*-2$"%&"3+&,&+2/+" /"#/+?"%&"#/)$7+/" 6.&"/"8$+*&"%-,3.)" "+&'/9:$"/$"
($)*+$'&"%&"($)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&"%&"'&-,A"L$?$B"3+&2-."%&"#/)&-+/")&?/*-2/"6.&"$"
)$2$"3+$(&%-#&)*$"%/"NO8"3$%&+-/"-)%-+&*/#&)*&"(+-/+".#/"+&'/9:$"
(/""0/2$+"%$"8$),&'
(PUHVSRVWDLPHGLDWDj&RUWHGH&DVVDomRR&RQVHOKR&RQVWLWXFLRQDO DUD
?.#&)*$."($#"$"-)*.-*$"%&"%$),*+/+"/"($#3/*-7-'-%/%&"%/"NO8"($#"/,"$7+-D
?/9Q&,"($#.)-*P+-/,"%$"M.-;")/(-$)/'dGA"]/"+&0&+-%/"%&(-,:$B"$"8$),&'8$),*-D
*.(-$)/'"&43|,"%&*/'%/#&)*&"$,"3$%&+&,"6.&"$"M.-;"$+%-)P+-$"3$,,.-B"/",/7&+B"
/"3$,,-7-'-%/%&"%&"/3+&,&)*/+".#/"6.&,*:$"3+&M.%-(-/'"($)($#-*/)*&)*&B"$."
/3>,"$" 3+$(&%-#&)*$"%/"NO8R" $"3$%&+" %&"($)*+$'/+"/" ($)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&"%/,"
'&-,".#/"2&;"($)('.@%$"$"3+$(&%-#&)*$"%/" NO8R"/,,-#"($#$"*/#7V#"$"3$%&+"
GHWRPDUPHGLGDVSURYLVyULDVRXFDXWHODUHVFRPRLQWXLWRGHSUHVHUYDUDH´FiD
(-/"3'&)/"%$"%-+&-*$"%/"U)-:$"I.+$3&-/d^A
3RVWHULRUPHQWHHPUHVSRVWDjTXHVWmRSUHMXGLFLDODSUHVHQWDGDSHOD&RUWH
%&"8/,,/9:$B"$"X+-7.)/'"%&"n.,*-9/"%/"U)-:$"I.+$3&-/"+&($)(/+P*&+"3+-$D
+-*P+-$"%/" NO8"+&0$+9/)%$"/" 3/+*-'"%&"*/+&0/," &'/7$+/%/"3&'$" 8$),&'D
*-*.(-$)/'db DOpPGH D´UPDU TXH R FRQWUROHGH FRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDGHUHSUHVVLYR
-)*+$%.;-%$"3&'/" NO8"):$"($)*+/%-;" $"/+*-?$"J^bdH"%$"X+/*/%$",$7+&"$"C.)(-$D
)/#&)*$"%/"U)-:$"I.+$3&-/B"%&,%&"6.&"$,"*+-7.)/-,"$+%-)P+-$,",&M/#"'-2+&,"3/+/k
/i"N.&,*-$)/+" $" XnUI"/" +&,3&-*$" %&".#/" 6.&,*:$" 3+&M.%-(-/'"/" 6./'6.&+"
#$#&)*$"h#&,#$"/3>,".#"-)(-%&)*&"%&"($)*+$'&"%&"($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&iR
dc" 8$+*&"%&"8/,,/9:$B"E^"%&"/7+-'"%&"JKEKB")a"EKDcKAKKJA Ver anexo.
dG" S&(-,:$"){"JKEKD^KGB"S&(-,:$"%&"8$)0$+#-%/%&"%&"EJ"%&"#/-$"%&"JKEKA
d^" [%AB"JKEJB"3A"GEA
db" 'HFLVmRGR7-8(GHGHMXQKRGHQ&H&0HONLH$EGHOL9HUDQH[R
dH" _+*-?$"J^bA{"S!"XT_X_S!"\!mTI"!"CU]8[!]_WI]X!"S_"U][`!"IUT!OI[_"h/)*&+-$+&,"
Ebb{"&"Jdc{"%$"X+/*/%$"8Iik
!"X+-7.)/'"%&"n.,*-9/"%/"U)-:$"I.+$3&-/"V"($#3&*&)*&"3/+/"%&(-%-+B"/"*@*.'$"3+&M.%-(-/'k
/i"\$7+&"/"-)*&+3+&*/9:$"%$,"X+/*/%$,R
7i"\$7+&" /" 2/'-%/%&" &" /" -)*&+3+&*/9:$" %$," /*$," /%$*/%$," 3&'/," -),*-*.-9Q&,B" $," >+?:$," $." $,"
$+?/)-,#$,"%/"U)-:$R"
\+&"6.&".#/"6.&,*:$"%&,*/")/*.+&;/",&M/",.,(-*/%/""3+$(&,,$" 3&)%&)*&"3&+/)*&".#">+D
?:$"M.+-,%-(-$)/'")/(-$)/'"(.M/,"%&(-,Q&,"):$",&M/#",.,(&3*@2&-,"%&"+&(.+,$"M.%-(-/'"3+&2-,*$"
)$"%-+&-*$"-)*&+)$B"&,,&">+?:$"V"$7+-?/%$"/",.7#&*&+"/"6.&,*:$"/$"X+-7.)/'A
"_"TIL_x`!"I]XTI"U][`!"IUT!OI[_"I"_"NUI\X `!"OT[!T[XyT[_""Ebb"
"SI"8!]\X[XU8[!]_L[S_SI"S!"S[TI[X!"CT_]8z\
7i"_%$*/+"/,"#&%-%/,")&(&,,P+-/,"3/+/" ?/+/)*-+"/"3+$*&67&0H$5;-;()0C+&*;,
VyULDGHGLUHLWRVFRQIHULGRVSHOD$+%"M.+@%-(/"%/"U)-:$"I.+$3&-/R
(i"S&-4/+"%&"/3'-(/+"/"'&?-,'/9:$")/(-$)/'"$7M&*$"%&"/)P'-,&B")/"*&,&"%&"
DFRQVLGHUDUHPFRQWUiULDjOHJLVODomRGD8(dFA
]$"&)*/)*$B"".#/" %&(-,:$"%&"JF"%&"M.)cKB" /"8$+*&"%&"8/,,/9:$"
($),-%&+$.B"3$+" +/;Q&,"%&"3+$(&%-#&)*$B" 6.&"/"3+-$+-%/%&" %&"&4/#&"%/" NO8"
QmRHUDDSOLFiYHOj&RUWHQDKLSyWHVHTXHWLYHVVHUHFHELGRXPTXHVWLRQDPHQWR
6.&"/7+/)?&,,&"/" ($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&"&" /"($)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&"%&" .#/"%-,3$,-D
9:$"'&?-,'/*-2/A
_"($)*+$2V+,-/",$7+&"$"(/+P*&+"3+-$+-*P+-$"%/"NO8"):$"0$-"*$*/'#&)*&"+&,$'D
YLGDHWDOIDWR SRGHUiMXVWL´FDUDLQWHUYHQomRGR OHJLVODGRUEXVFDQGRFRQIHULU
j&RUWHGH &DVVDomRR SRGHUGHDGRWDU DVPHGLGDVSURYLVyULDV RXFDXWHODUHV
6.&"/"3&+#-*-+-/#" (.#3+-+"$"($)M.)*$"%&" &4-?1)(-/,"&,*/7&'&(-%/,"3&'$"X+-7.D
)/'"%&"n.,*-9/" %/"U)-:$" I.+$3&-/A"I#"($)('.,:$B" &)*&)%&D,&"6.&")/" 3+P*-(/"/"
?.&++/"&)*+&"M.@;&,"):$"%&,*+.-."/"3+-$+-%/%&"%/"NO8A"O&'$"($)*+P+-$B" 2-,*$"6.&"
RSULQFtSLRGRFDUiWHUSULRULWiULRGH´QLGR SHOD/HL2UJkQLFDGHHHVSHFLD
´FDGRSHOR &RQVHOKR&RQVWLWXFLRQDO HVWiVDOYDJXDUGDGRH DWpUHIRUoDGR SHOD
,./"($#3/*-7-'-%/%&"($#"$"S-+&-*$" %/"U)-:$"I.+$3&-/B"2&)%$"/")&(&,,-%/%&"
/-)%/"%&" 6.&",&M/#" +&/'-;/%$,"/'?.)," /M.,*&,"%&" 3+$(&%-#&)*$B"/M.,*&," &,*&,"
6.&",:$"/#3'/#&)*&"2-P2&-,cEA
_3&,/+"%$" 6.&,*-$)/#&)*$" /" +&,3&-*$" %$" (/+P*&+" 3+-$+-*P+-$" %/" NO8" *&+"
,-%$"3$+"$+/",$'.(-$)/%$B",&"0/;")&(&,,P+-$"/3$)*/+"6.&"/.*$+&,B"($#$"/"3+$0&,D
,$+/"%&"%-+&-*$"357'-($")/"U)-2&+,-%/%&"%&"8/&)"m/,,&D]$+#/)%-/B"W/+-&Dn$&''&"
T&%$+DC-( .#/"7/-4/"/.*$)$#-/" %&"&,($'" %$"8$),&'
8$),*-*.(-$)/'")$"6.&"%-;"+&,3&-*$"/$"%-+&-*$"&.+$3&.B"-,*$"3$+6.&"/$"+&/'-;/+"$"
($)*+$'&"%&"($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&B"$"8$),&'
&4-,*1)(-/"%$" ($)*+$'&"%&"($)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&" &4&+(-%$"3&'$," M.@;&,"$+%-)P+-$,B"
,$7"+-,($"%&"($)%&)/9:$"3&'/"8$+*&"I.+$3&-/"%&"S-+&-*$,"j.#/)$,"$."3&'$"
L$?$B"T&%$+DC-( %&0&)%&"6.&"$" ($)*+$'&"%&" ($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&"+&/'-D
]DGRHP VHGHGH 43&RFRUUHVRE LQµXrQFLDGLUHWD GRGLUHLWR GD8QLmR (XURD
3&-/B"&"-,*$",&"%P")&(&,,/+-/#&)*&"3$+"($)*/"%/"&)*+/%/""2-?$+"%$"X+/*/%$"%&"
L-,7$/cJ"" JKKFB" %$(.#&)*$"M.+-%-(/#&)*&" 2-)(.'/*-2$B"6.&" 0$-"+&,3$),P2&'"
dF" 'HFLVmRGR7-8(GHGHMXQKRGHQ&H&0HONLH$EGHOL9HUDQH[R
cK" Corte de Cassação, 29 de junho de 2010, nº 12132.
cE" [%AB"JKEJA"3A"GJA
cJ" !"X+/*/%$" %&"L-,7$/"&)*+$." "2-?$+"" E"%&" %&;+$"%&"JKKFB" 3$)%$"/,,-#"*&+#$" /"
2P+-$,"/)$,"%&")&?$(-/9Q&,",$7+&"6.&,*Q&,"-),*-*.(-$)/-,A
!"X+/*/%$"%&"L-,7$/"/'*&+/B","$," ,.7,*-*.-+B"$,"*+/*/%$,"%/"U)-:$"I.+$3&-/"&"%/" 8$#.)-%/%&"
(XURSHLDDFWXDOPHQWHHP YLJRU27UDWDGRFRQIHUH j8QLmRR TXDGURMXUtGLFRHRV LQVWUXD
PHQWRVQHFHVViULRV SDUD ID]HU IDFH D GHVD´RV IXWXURV H UHVSRQGHU jV H[SHFWDWLYDV GRV
FLGDGmRV'LVSRQtYHOHPKWWSHXURSDHXOLVERQBWUHDW\JODQFHLQGH[BSWKWP
EbH"TIZ[\X_"S!"OT!YT_W_"SI"S[TI[X!"S_"U][`!"IUT!OI[_
3$+"($),*-*.-+".#/"+&0&+1)(-/"3/+/"/"8/+*/"%$,"S-+&-*$,"C.)%/#&)*/-,"%/"U)-:$"
I.+$3&-/A
S&,*/"0$+#/B" */)*$")$" ($)*+$'&"3+&2&)*-2$"6./)*$" )$",-,*/" %/"NO8B" $"
8$),&' ($),*/*/+P"6.&"$," %-+&-*$,"&"'-7&+D
%/%&,"?/+/)*-%$," 3&'/" 8$),*-*.-9:$",&+:$" &0&*-2/#&)*&" (/+/(*&+-;/%$,"($#$"
&6.-2/'&)*&,"/$,"($),/?+/%$,"3&'/"U)-:$"I.+$3&-/B"3$+"#/-,"6.&"$,"($)*&5%$,"
%$,"%-3'$#/,"3$,,/#"2-+"/",&+""/'?.#/"#&%-%/",.*-'#&)*&"%-,*-)*$,A
L$?$B"/" /.*$+/"&)*&)%&"6.&" /"%&3&)%1)(-/" %$"M.-;"($),*-*.(-$)/'" "+&D
'/9:$"/$" ($)*+$'&"%&" ($)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&"&43'-(/" "3/+*&"/" /#7-?.-%/%&"%/,"
,$'.9Q&,"/%$*/%/,B"&,3&(-/'#&)*&" 6./)%$"$" 8$),&' /"/(&-*/+".#"
%&*&+#-)/%$" 3+-)(@3-$" " #/*V+-/" %&" %-+&-*$," &" '-7&+%/%&," ?/+/)*-%$," 3&'/"
8$),*-*.-9:$A"!"+-,($"%&"%&,&)2$'2-#&)*$"3$,*&+-$+"%&"M.+-,3+.%1)(-/"&.+$3&-/"
-)(&)*-2/"6.&" %&"0/*$"):$" 2&)"/"&)(&++/+" 3&+#/)&)*&)*&"/" (/*&?$+-/"%&"
%-+&-*$,"%$,"'-*-?/)*&,")$"l#7-*$"%/"NO8A
I#"($)*+/3/+*-%/B" /3&,/+"%/" 3+$4-#-%/%&"&)*+&" $,"($)*+$'&,"%&" ($)2&)D
(-$)/'-%/%&"&"%&" ($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&B"V")&(&,,P+-$"/3$)*/+" .#/"+&'&2/)*&"%-,D
*-)9:$"&,*/7&'&(-%/"3$+"W/+("Y.-''/.#&B"&,3&(-/'#&)*&")$" 6.&"*/)?&"/$"3/3&'"
%$"8$),&'%/"8$+*&"I.+$3&-/"%&"S-+&-*$,"j.#/)$,A"!"\&(+&D
*P+-$"Y&+/'"%$"8$),&'$+/"/"NO8"&"$"&)(/#-D
QKDPHQWRGHXPD TXHVWmRj&RUWHSRVVXDP D´QDOLGDGHFRPXPGH SURWHomR
%$,"%-+&-*$,"&"'-7&+%/%&,B"):$"3$,,."$"#&,#$"$7M&*$A
\&?.)%$"Y.-''/.#&B"/"NO8"V".#"-)(-%&)*&"%&)*+$"%&".#"3+$(&,,$""(.+D
,$"6.&" 6.&,*-$)/" /"($)0$+#-%/%&" %/"'&-" ($#"/" 8$),*-*.-9:$B" /$"3/,,$" 6.&"/"
8$+*&"I.+$3&-/"%&" S-+&-*$,"j.#/)$,"):$" V"($#3&*&)*&"3/+/" ($)*+$'/+"/"($)D
IRUPLGDGHGHXPDOHLHPUHODomR j&RQYHQomRPDVVLPpTXHVWLRQDGDHPFDD
,$,"3/+*-(.'/+&,"&"*$#/"($) '-7&+%/%&,"%&D
($++&)*&,"%/"/3'-(/9:$"%/"'&-A
S&"(&+*/"#/)&-+/B"&,*/"3/+&(&",&+".#/"-#3$+*/)*&"%-0&+&)(-/9:$"+&0&+&)*&"
/$,"%$-,"#$%&'$,"%&"($)*+$'&"&"6.&"%&"/'?.#/"#/)&-+/"/0/,*/"%52-%/,"/"+&,3&-D
*$"%&".#",.3$,*$"/)*/?$)-,#$"&)*+&"$"($)*+$'&"%&"($),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&"%/"NO8"
&"$"($)*+$'&"%&"($)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&"%/"U)-:$"I.+$3&-/A
I010:&3-)$#7&
!"3+&,&)*&"*+/7/' *+/*$."%&"&'/7$+/+" .#/"3$,,@2&'"+&'/9:$" &)*+&"/"N.&,*:$"
O+-$+-*P+-/"%&" 8$),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&"=" 3$+"#&-$" %$"($)*+$'&" %&"($),*-*.(-$)/'-D
%/%&"&)*+&"/,"'&-," -)*&+)/,"&"/,")$+#/,"($#" ,*/*.,"($),*-*.(-$)/'"-),&+-%/,")$"
m'$($"%&"8$),*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&"C+/)(1,"6.&"V"+&/'-;/%$"3&'$"8$),&'
FLRQDOHVSHFL´FDPHQWHQRTXH GL]UHVSHLWRDRVGLUHLWRVHOLEHUGDGHV FRQVWLWXD
(-$)/-,B"="&"$" S-+&-*$"%/"U)-:$"I.+$3&-/" ="/*+/2V,"%$"($)*+$'&" %&"($)2&)(-$D
)/'-%/%&"&0&*./%$"3&'$," M.@;&,"$+%-)P+-$,"0+/)(&,&," h,&M/#"$+-.)%$,"%/"&,0&+/"
"_"TIL_x`!"I]XTI"U][`!"IUT!OI[_"I"_"NUI\X `!"OT[!T[XyT[_""EbF"
"SI"8!]\X[XU8[!]_L[S_SI"S!"S[TI[X!"CT_]8z\
M.%-(-/'"$."/%#-)-,*+/*-2/i"&)*+&" /,"'&-,"-)*&+)/,"&"$," *+/*/%$,"&"($#3+$#-,,$,"
-)*&+)/(-$)/-,A
O/+/"-,,$"+&/'-;$.D,&".#/"/)P'-,&",$7+&"$"#&(/)-,#$"%/"NO8B",./,"(/+/(D
WHUtVWLFDVHVSHFL´FLGDGHVPDQHLUDFRPRVHGiRH[DPHGHFRPSDWLELOLGDGHHQD
*+&"/,"%-,3$,-9Q&,"'&?-,'/*-2/,"&"/,")$+#/,"%&",*/*.,"($),*-*.(-$)/'"&"$,"&0&-*$,"
%&",./,"%&(-,Q&,B" ($#"$" $7M&*-2$"3+-)(-3/'"%&" &,('/+&(&+"$"0.)(-$)/#&)*$" %$"
/-)%/"):$"#.-*$"($)
,-2$"0+/)(1,A
I,*/"/3+&,&)*/9:$" 0$-" )&(&,,P+-/" 3/+/" 6.&" ,&" 3.%&,,&" &)*&)%&+" %&" 6.&"
#/)&-+/"V" 3$,,@2&'"&,*/7&'&(&+".#/" +&'/9:$"&)*+&" /"NO8" &"$"%-+&-*$" &.+$3&.B"
*&)%$"" 2-,*/" 6.&" $" ($)*+$'&" %$" #&(/)-,#$" " 6.&,*:$" *" 3$+" $7M&*-2$"
3+-)(-3/'"3+$*&?&+"/,"'-7&+%/%&,"&"$,"%-+&-*$,"($),*-*.(-$)/-,A"S-+&-*$,"&,*&,"6.&"
*/#7V#",:$"+&,?./+%/%$,")$"l#7-*$"%/"U)-:$"I.+$3&-/B".)-0$+#&)*&B"3&'/"
8/+*/"%$," S-+&-*$,"C.)%/#&)*/-," %/" U)-:$"I.+$3&-/B" $"6.&" %&"(&+*/" #/)&-+/"
3$%&+-/"?&+/+".#/" &,3V(-&"%&"/)*/?$)-,#$" &)*+&"($)*+$'&"%&" ($),*-*.(-$)/'-D
%/%&"&"($)*+$'&"%&"($)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&A
!"/%2&)*$"%/"NO8"0$-"-)$2/%$+"&"+&,3$),P2&'"3$+".#/"+&0$+#/"#.-*$"+&'&D
2/)*&")$"(&)P+-$"M.+@%-($"0+/)(1,A"C$-"+&,3$),P2&'"3$+" +&/3+$4-#/+"$"8$),&'
8$),*-*.(-$)/'"&"/" 8$+*&"I.+$3&-/"%&" S-+&-*$,"j.#/)$,B" 6.&"%&,%&"EFbG" 3$.D
($",&"($#.)-(/2/#B"/'V#"%&"+&)$2/+" 3+$0.)%/#&)*&"$"#$%$"%&"/3'-(/9:$"%/"
8ISj"/$"8$),&'
!"+-,($"%&"-)($#3/*-7-'-%/%&",.,(-*/%$"&)*+&"$,"%$-,"($)*+$'&,B"&)*+&*/)*$B"
IRLDIDVWDGRSRUPHLRGHXPDGHFLVmRGR7-8(TXH GH´QLXTXHD43&QmRHUD
FRQWUiULDjVGLVSRVLo}HVGR7)8(DOpPGHWHUUHFRQKHFLGRVHXFDUiWHUSULRULWiD
ULR$LQGDTXHWHQKDPVLGROHYDQWDGDVFUtWLFDVjLQGHSHQGrQFLDGRFRQWUROHGH
FRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDGHGD43&FRPRVHYHUL´FRXIDWRpTXHVHXVEHQHItFLRVSDUD
$,"'-*-?/)*&,",:$"&0&*-2/#&)*&"+&($)&"
FRPSOHPHQWDULHGDGH©DLQGDTXHQmR H[WUHPDPHQWHSDFt´FDWHQGRHPYLVWD
$,",.3+/(-*/%$,"-)*&+&,,&,"%/"8$+*&"%&"8/,,/9:$"="&)*+&"$,"($)*+$'&,"%&"($),D
*-*.(-$)/'-%/%&"&"($)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&A
$SHVDUGRVTXHVWLRQDPHQWRVpSRVVtYHOD´UPDUTXHDXWLOLGDGHGDUHIRUPD
V"('/+/#&)*&"($),*/*/%/B"&,3&(-/'#&)*&"3$+6.&"($#$",&"$7,&+2$."$"$7M&*$"%$,"
%$-,"($)*+$'&," V"%&" 0/*$"%-,*-)*$A" L$?$B"/," #.%/)9/,")$" ($)*&)(-$,$"0+/)(1,B"
($),&6.1)(-/,"%/"T&0$+#/"8$),*-*.(-$)/'"%&"JKKHB"3$,,."(/+/(*&+@,*-(/,"%&"
UHYROXomRMXUtGLFDHGHPRFUiWLFDHIRUDPUHVSRQViYHLVSRUFRQIHULUj43&XPD
($),-%&+P2&'"2/)*/?""%&*+-#&)*$"%$"($)*+$'&"%&"($)2&)(-$)/'-%/%&A
,VWRSRUTXH QR FRQWUROHGH FRQYHQFLRQDOLGDGH YHUL´FDVHDSHQDV DSRVD
,-7-'-%/%&"%&" /"/3'-(/9:$"%/" '&-",&+" /0/,*/%/"".#" (/,$"($)(+&*$A" !.",&M/B"/"
+&0&+-%/"'&-"3&+#/)&(&")$" $+%&)/#&)*$"M.+@%-($B"$"6.&" ?&+/"$"+-,($"%&" /"#&,D
#/"&2&)*./'#&)*&",&+"/3'-(/%/"3$+"*+-7.)/-,"-)0&+-$+&,B"/$"3/,,$"6.&B"($#$",&"
EHK"TIZ[\X_"S!"OT!YT_W_"SI"S[TI[X!"S_"U][`!"IUT!OI[_
$7,&+2$.B".#/"%/,"($),&6.1)(-/,"%/"%&(-,:$"%&" ):$"($)0$+#-%/%&"%/"'&-"6.&"
/0&*/"%-+&-*$,"&"'-7&+%/%&,"($),*-*.(-$)/-,B"",&%&"%&"NO8B"V",./"+&2$?/9:$"&"
&43.+?/9:$"%$"$+%&)/#&)*$"M.+@%-($"0+/)(1,A
©5HIHUrQFLDVELEOLRJUi´FDV
2010@B+(#0"0(+4;E
mUTSI_UB" Y&$+?&,A" 'URLW &RQVWLWXWLRQQHO HW ,QVWLWXWLRQV 3ROLWLTXHV" C+/)9/k"
L-7+/-+-&"YV)V+/'&"%&"S+$-*"&*"%&"n.+-,3+.%&)(&B"EFHKA"EFf"&%-9:$A
mUTSI_UB"Y&$+?&,A"j_W!]B"C+/)(-,A"XT!OITB"W-(=(3$")0>+&;40:&3#4;4$,
4;&33"))"A"O/+-,k"L-7+/-+-&" YV)V+/'&"%&"S+$-*"&*" %&"n.+-,3+.%&)(&B"EFFbA" JGf"&%-D
9:$A
8_T8_\\!]]IB" Y.~A" SUj_WILB" !'-2-&+A" J':K0 D(0 J$"#4;&30 '+;&+;4(;+"0 5"0
:&3#4;4$4;&33();4L?"C+/)9/k"S/''$;B"JKEEA"EcH"3A
SUj_WILB" !'-2-&+A" /H SRXYRLU SROLWLTXH HQ )UDQFHA" S+$-*" 8$),*-*.*-$))&'B" EA"
C+/)9/k"O+&,,&,"U)-2&+,-*/-+&,"%&"C+/)(&B"EFFEA"Ef"&%-9:$A
T!U\\I_UB"S$#-)-6.&A"m!]]IXB"n.'-&)A"/HVVHQFLHOGHOD43&0RGHGHPSORL
5"0)(0J$"#4;&30'+;&+;4(;+"05"0:&3#4;4$4;&33();4L?0O/+-,k"Y./'-)$B"JKEJA"Jf"&%-9:$A
22010MN4;*;+4$(;#
_(>+%:$"%$" X+-7.)/'"%&" n.,*-9/" %/,"8$#.)-%/%&," I.+$3&-/,A"F" %&" #/+9$"%&"
EFbHA"3URFHVVRª6LPPHQWKDO«"S-,3$)@2&'"k"‚
3+&,,A($#uJKEduK^uEGu,-##&)*'DEFbHuƒ"_(&,,$""KG"M.)A"JKEcA
_[L[]8_[B"WAB"/D&-8(VHSURQRQFHVXUODFRQIRUPLWp DXGURLWFRPPXQDXWDLUH
5$0-(+(-4O+"0C+;&+;4(;+"05"0)(0 J':A"S-,3$)@2&'"k"‚
7'&A0+u#/)-0&,*/*-$),u'/D(M.&D,&D3+$)$)(&D,.+D'/D($)0$+#-*&D/.D%+$-*D($##.D
)/.*/-+&D%.D(/+/(*&+&D3+-$+-*/-+&D%&D'/D63(D3/+D#D/-'-)(/-DEK^E^EA
"KF"M.)A"JKEcA
_O8j_[]B"jV's)&A"D(0J':0"40)"0-&34+P)"05"0-&3*"34;&33();4LQ0-&%C)L%"34(+;,
4L0&$0(34(E&3;#%"R0S-,3$)@2&'"k" ‚
/3(-)63(((A3%0ƒ"_(&,,$""KF"M.)A"JKEcA
m_8jITXB"_.%+&~A":&34+&)"0>"0:&3#4;4$4;&33();4L0 "40:&34+&)"0>"0:&3*"34;&,
33();4LQ0S"+#0 D(0'+;%($4L0 TB#&)$"0 >$0>+&;40 :&%%$3($4(;+"R0S-,3$)@2&'" k"
"_"TIL_x`!"I]XTI"U][`!"IUT!OI[_"I"_"NUI\X `!"OT[!T[XyT[_""EHE"
"SI"8!]\X[XU8[!]_L[S_SI"S!"S[TI[X!"CT_]8z\
‚
&\EHUGRFV0)(EDFKHUWBDSGIEDFKHUWBDSGI!$FHVVRHPMXQ
m_Tm!\_B" n$/6.-#A" U*&)$67&0 5&0 -&34+&)"0 5"0 -&3#4;4$-;&3();5(5"0 5"0 4;C&0
IUDQFrVA" [)A" T&2-,*/" %&" [)0$+#/9:$" L&?-,'/*-2/A" /A" cK" )A" EGH" /7+AuM.)A" m+/,@'-/k"
JKKdA" S-,3$)@2&'" k" ‚"
-%uHcbuTEGHDKcA3%0€,&6.&)(&„c"ƒ"_(&,,$""KG"M.)A"JKEcA
mTU8IB"I2/A" :@VW!@DU0 >U0 :@VMW2WXW2@VVTD2WU0 UW:@VW!@DU0 >U0 :@V,
9(17,211$/,7(5pµH[LRQV DXWRXUGH ODUWLFOH GH OD &RQVWLWXWLRQ GDQV
)(0H$+;#C+$5"3-"0 5$0 :&3#";)0 -&3#4;4$4;&33")?"S-,3$)@2&'"k"‚*3kuuvvvA%+$-D
*($),*-*.*-$))&'A$+?u($)?+&,#*3u*&4*&,GumTU8IJA3%0ƒ"_(&,,$""KF"M.)A"JKEcA
SI" L_W!XjIB" !'-2-&+" S.*:&34+P)"0 5"0 -&3*"34;&33();4L0 "40 -&34+P)"0 5"0
-&3#4;4$4;&33();4L0"30Y+(3-"?"Z-,-*&"/."X+-7.)/'"8$),*-*.*-$))&'"I,3/?)$'B"W/%+-%B"
JDc"%&"_7+-'"%&"JKKFA"S-,3$)@2&'"k"‚D
VHLO FRQVWLWXWLRQQHOURRWEDQNBPPSGI&RQVHLOPDGULGBRGXWKHLOOHWBDYULOB
3%0ƒ"_(&,,$""KE"M.)A"JKEcA
S[]X[Lj_8B" n&/)DO-&++&" \_TY!\B" O-&++&" &*" …ImITB" n&/)DC+/)9$-,A0 D"0 5+&;40
HXURSpHQHVWLOVROXEOHGDQVODTXHVWLRQSULRULWDLUHGHFRQVWLWXWLRQQDOLWp" S-,D
3$)@2&'" k" ‚
3&&)D&,*D-'D,$'.7'&D%/),D'/D6.&,*-$)D3+-$+-*/-+&D%&D($),*-*.*-$))/'-*&D3/+DM&/)D
SLHUUHGLQWLOKDFSLHUUHVDUJRVHWMHDQIUDQFRLVZHEHUBBKWPO!
_(&,,$""KF"M.)A"JKEcA
j_I]ILB" j.7&+*A" &RQWU{OH 'H &RQVWLWXWLRQQDOLWp (W 'URLW 'H /XQLRQ (XUR,
CL"33"A" S-,3$)@2&'" k" ‚
WLWXWLRQQHOURRWEDQNBPPGLVFRXUVBLQWHUYHQWLRQVKDHQHOSGI!
_(&,,$""KF"M.)A"JKEcA
YU[LL_UWIB"W/+(A"D(0J$"#4;&30'+;&+;4(;+"0 5"0:&3#4;4$4;&33();4LA"[)k"n.,*-(&"&*"
8/,,/*-$)B"+&2.&"/)).&''&"%&,"/2$(/*,"/."8$),&-'"%o†*/*"&*"'/"8$.+"%&"8/,,/*-$)A"
JKEKA" S-,3$)@2&'" k" ‚
WLRQQHOURRWEDQNBPP43&TSFBPJXLOODXPHBIHYSGIƒ" _(&,,$" " KH"
M.)A"JKEcA
YU[LL_UWIB"W/+(A" J$"#4;&30 '+;&+;4(;+"0 >"0 :&3#4;4$4;&33();4L0 U40 :&3*"34;&30
(XURSpHQQH 'HV 'URLWV 'H /KRPPH 1RXYHDX[ &DKLHUV GX &RQVHLO FRQVWL,
WXWLRQQHOQ 'RVVLHU&RQYHQWLRQ HXURSpHQQH GHVGURLWV GHOKRPPH ©
EHJ"TIZ[\X_"S!"OT!YT_W_"SI"S[TI[X!"S_"U][`!"IUT!OI[_
Z$).&05"0 9F//?0 S-,3$)@2&'" k" ‚
D($),*-*.*-$))&'u+$$*u7/)wu3%0u($),&-'D($),*-*.*-$))&'DFFKG^A3%0ƒ" _(&,,$"
"KJ"/?$A"JKEcA
YU[LL_UWI"W/+(A" J':Q0 4"<4"#0 (CC);-(B)"#0 "40 C+"%;O+"#0 5L-;#;&3#?0 D"#0 3&$,
YHDX[FDKLHUVGX&RQVHLO FRQVWLWXWLRQQHOQGRVVLHU ODTXHVWLRQSULRULWDL,
+"0 5"0 -&3#4;4$4;&33();4L?" S-,3$)@2&'" k" ‚
0+u($),&-'D($),*-*.*-$))&'u+$$*u7/)wu3%0u($),&-'D($),*-*.*-$))&'DGJbdKA3%0ƒ"
_(&,,$""Kd"/?$A"JKEcA
TIS!TDC[8j!XB"W/+-&Dn$&''&A" /H &RQVHLO &RQVWLWXWLRQQHO OD TXHVWLRQ SULRUL,
WDLUHGHFRQVWLWXWLRQQDOLWpHOHV GURLWVHWOLEHUWpVTXHOD&RQVWLWXWLRQ JDUDQWLW"
8ISCB"){" FB"JKEEB"3A" cEDGdA"S-,3$)@2&'" k"‚
+&2.&,u(+%0u(+%0Fu(+%0KFKc+&%$+A3%0ƒ"_(&,,$""KF"M.)A"JKEcA
[010T3"
7,./0/8'2#49$/*&/1$"%'/*'/1&44&:9$/;'"&/?@*#2#&=/>"&A2'4&B
)CCDE/FG/.-.HH/8I/-J/KILF/-M.M/;.MNOM,MM-B//
0/PIQRELSF/!CLSCLE)LCQ/8Q/1SFRELEIELSFF)TLEU/0//
1SIC/8Q/1)RR)ELSF
Vu l’arrêt avant dire droit du 16 avril 2010 posant deux questions préju*
GLFLHOOHVjOD&RXUGHMXVWLFHGHO8QLRQHXURSpHQQH&-8(
9XODUUrWGHOD&-8(GXMXLQ
Attendu que M. X..., de nationalité algérienne, en situation irré*
JXOLqUHHQ)UDQFHD IDLWOREMHWHQDSSOLFDWLRQ GHODUWLFOHDOLQpD
GXFRGHGHSURFpGXUHSpQDOHGXQFRQWU{OHGHSROLFHGDQV OD]RQH
comprise entre la frontière terrestre de la France avec la Belgique et
XQHOLJQHWUDFpHjNLORPqWUHVHQGHojTXHOHPDUVOHSUp*
IHWGX1RUG OXLDQRWL´p XQDUUrWpGH UHFRQGXLWHjOD IURQWLqUHHWXQH
décision de maintien en rétention dans des locaux ne relevant pas de
ODGPLQLVWUDWLRQSpQLWHQWLDLUHTXHGHYDQWOHMXJHGHVOLEHUWpVHWGHOD
détention de Lille, saisi par le préfet d’une demande de prolongation
de cette rétention, M. X... a déposé un mémoire posant une question
SULRULWDLUHGHFRQVWLWXWLRQQDOLWpHW VRXWHQXTXHODUWLFOHDOLQpD
du code de procédure pénale portait atteinte aux droits et libertés
JDUDQWLVSDUOD&RQVWLWXWLRQ
"_"TIL_x`!"I]XTI"U][`!"IUT!OI[_"I"_"NUI\X `!"OT[!T[XyT[_""EHd"
"SI"8!]\X[XU8[!]_L[S_SI"S!"S[TI[X!"CT_]8z\
Attendu que, le 25 mars 2010, le juge des libertés et de la dé*
tention de Lille a ordonné la transmission à la Cour de cassation de la
TXHVWLRQVXLYDQWHªODUWLFOHDOLQpDSRUWHWLODWWHLQWHDX[GURLWV
et libertés garantis par la Constitution de la République française?” et
SURORQJpGHODUpWHQWLRQGH0;SRXUXQHGXUpHGHTXLQ]HMRXUVTXH
FHWWHRUGRQQDQFHDpWpUHoXHjOD&RXUGHFDVVDWLRQOHPDUV
$WWHQGXTXH SRXUVRXWHQLU TXH ODUWLFOH DOLQpD GX FRGH
de procédure pénale est contraire à la Constitution, le demandeur in*
YRTXHODUWLFOH GHFHOOHFLTXLGLVSRVHTXH ªOD5pSXEOLTXHSDUWLFL*
pe à l’Union européenne constituée d’Etats qui ont choisi librement
d’exercer en commun certaines de leurs compétences en vertu du
traité sur l’Union européenne et du traité sur le fonctionnement de
l’Union européenne, tels qu’ils résultent du traité signé à Lisbonne le
GpFHPEUH
4XLOIDLW YDORLUTXH OHVHQJDJHPHQWV UpVXOWDQWGX 7UDLWpGH /LV*
bonne, dont celui concernant la libre circulation des personnes, ont
XQHYDOHXU FRQVWLWXWLRQQHOOH DXUHJDUG GH ODUWLFOH GHOD &RQVWL*
WXWLRQTXH ODUWLFOH DOLQpD GX FRGHGH SURFpGXUHSpQDOH TXL
autorise des contrôles aux frontières intérieures des Etats membres
est contraire au principe de libre circulation des personnes posé
par l’article 67 du Traité de Lisbonne qui prévoit que l’Union assure
ODEVHQFHGHFRQWU{OHVGHVSHUVRQQHV DX[IURQWLqUHVLQWpULHXUHVTXLO
HQGpGXLWTXHODUWLFOHDOLQpDGXFRGHGHSURFpGXUHSpQDOHHVW
FRQWUDLUHjOD&RQVWLWXWLRQ
Attendu que, par arrêt avant dire droit du 16 avril 2010, la Cour de
cassation, constatant qu’était ainsi posée la question de la conformité de
ODUWLFOHDOLQpDGXFRGHGHODSURFpGXUHSpQDOHjODIRLVDXGURLW
de l’Union et à la Constitution de la République française, a posé deux
TXHVWLRQVSUpMXGLFLHOOHVjOD&RXUGHMXVWLFHGHO8QLRQHXURSpHQQH
Attendu, premièrement, que la CJUE a dit pour droit que l’article
267 TFUE s’oppose à une législation d’un Etat membre qui instaure une
procédure incidente de contrôle de constitutionnalité des lois nationa*
les, pour autant que le caractère prioritaire de cette procédure a pour
FRQVpTXHQFHGHPSrFKHUOHVMXULGLFWLRQVQDWLRQDOHVGH[HUFHUOHXU
faculté ou de satisfaire à leur obligation de saisir la Cour de questions
SUpMXGLFLHOOHVTXHQUHYDQFKH FHWDUWLFOHQH VRSSRVHSDVj XQHWHOOH
législation nationale pour autant que les juridictions restent libres:
— de saisir, à tout moment de la procédure qu’elles jugent appro*
prié, et même à l’issue de la procédure incidente de contrôle
EHc"TIZ[\X_"S!"OT!YT_W_"SI"S[TI[X!"S_"U][`!"IUT!OI[_
de constitutionnalité, la CJUE de toute question préjudicielle
qu’elles jugent nécessaire,
©GDGRSWHUWRXWHPHVXUHQpFHVVDLUHD´QGDVVXUHUODSURWHFWLRQ
juridictionnelle provisoire des droits conférés par l’ordre juridi*
que de l’Union, et
— de laisser inappliquée, à l’issue d’une telle procédure incidente,
la disposition législative nationale en cause si elles la jugent
FRQWUDLUHDX[GURLWVGHO8QLRQ
Attendu que le juge national chargé d’appliquer, dans le cadre
de sa compétence, les dispositions du droit de l’Union, a l’obligation
d’assurer le plein effet de ces normes en laissant au besoin inappli*
quée, de sa propre autorité, toute disposition contraire de la législa*
tion nationale, même postérieure, sans qu’il ait à demander ou à atten*
dre l’élimination préalable de celle ci par voie législative ou par tout
DXWUHSURFpGpFRQVWLWXWLRQQHO
Attendu que, dans l’hypothèse particulière où le juge est saisi
d’une question portant à la fois sur la constitutionnalité et la conven*
tionnalité d’une disposition législative, il lui appartient de mettre en
oeuvre, le cas échéant, les mesures provisoires ou conservatoires pro*
pres à assurer la protection juridictionnelle des droits conférés par
ORUGUH MXULGLTXH HXURSpHQ TXHQ FDV GLPSRVVLELOLWp GH VDWLVIDLUH j
cette exigence, comme c’est le cas de la Cour de cassation, devant
laquelle la procédure ne permet pas de recourir à de telles mesures,
le juge doit se prononcer sur la conformité de la disposition critiquée
au regard du droit de l’Union en laissant alors inappliquées les dispo*
VLWLRQVGHORUGRQQDQFH GXQRYHPEUH PRGL´pHSUpYR\DQWXQH
SULRULWpGH[DPHQGHODTXHVWLRQGHFRQVWLWXWLRQQDOLWp
Attendu, deuxièmement, que la Cour de justice de l’Union euro*
péenne a également dit pour droit que l’article 67, paragraphe 2, TFUE
DLQVLTXHOHVDUWLFOHVHW GXUqJOHPHQW&(QGX3DU*
lement européen et du Conseil, du 15 mars 2006, établissant un code
communautaire relatif au régime de franchissement des frontières par
OHVSHUVRQQHV FRGH IURQWLqUHV6FKHQJHQ VRSSRVHQWj XQHOpJLVOD*
tion nationale conférant aux autorités de police de l’Etat membre con*
cerné la compétence de contrôler, uniquement dans une zone de 20
kilomètres à partir de la frontière terrestre de cet Etat avec les parties
jODFRQYHQWLRQGDSSOLFDWLRQGHODFFRUGGH6FKHQJHQGXMXLQ
entre les gouvernements des Etats de l’Union économique Benelux,
de la République fédérale d’Allemagne et de la République française
relatif à la suppression graduelle des contrôles aux frontières com*
"_"TIL_x`!"I]XTI"U][`!"IUT!OI[_"I"_"NUI\X `!"OT[!T[XyT[_""EHG"
"SI"8!]\X[XU8[!]_L[S_SI"S!"S[TI[X!"CT_]8z\
PXQHVVLJQp j6FKHQJHQ/X[HPERXUJ OH MXLQ OLGHQWLWpGH
toute personne, indépendamment du comportement de celle*ci et des
circonstances particulières établissant un risque d’atteinte à l’ordre
SXEOLFHQ YXHGHYpUL´HU OHUHVSHFWGHV REOLJDWLRQVGH GpWHQWLRQGH
port et de présentation des titres et documents prévus par la loi, sans
prévoir l’encadrement nécessaire de cette compétence garantissant
que l’exercice pratique de ladite compétence ne puisse pas revêtir un
HIIHWpTXLYDOHQWjFHOXLGHVYpUL´FDWLRQVDX[IURQWLqUHV
4XHGqV ORUVTXH ODUWLFOH DOLQpD GX FRGHGH SURFpGXUH
pénale n’est assorti d’aucune disposition offrant une telle garantie, il
appartient au juge des libertés et de la détention d’en tirer les consé*
quences au regard de la régularité de la procédure dont il a été saisi,
sans qu’il y ait lieu de renvoyer au Conseil constitutionnel la question
SRVpH
!)C/1QR/VSELWR(
DIT N’Y AVOIR LIEU A RENVOYER au Conseil constitutionnel la ques*
tion prioritaire de constitutionnalité
!"X4#*'A%(/V,/T&
C&66$"%'@"(/V,/W&=2$A'Y/2$A4'#=='"Y/&44#4%X/*'/V,/Z$"['#\Y/&@*#%'@"/&@/
R'"+#2'/*'/*$2@
)+$2&%/]XAX"&=(/V,/8$
)+$2&%;4B(/R1!/^&5@'%Y/W&"]'/'%/_&[&A
'LVSRQtYHO HP KWWSFRXUGHFDVVDWLRQIUFRXUBFDVVDWLRQBVDYRLUBSOXVBLQVWLD
WXWLRQB$FHVVRHPDJR
7,-/0/8'2#49$/*$/E"#`@A&=/*'/K@4%#:&/*&/IA#9$/Q@"$6'#&
)CCDE/8Q/T)/1SIC/;]"&A*'/2a&
rT&)2$-"3+VM.%-(-&'"=" _+*-('&"J^b" XCUI"="I4/#&)" %&"'/"($)0$+#-*V"
%o.)&"'$-")/*-$)/'&"*/)*"/2&("'&"%+$-*"%&"'oU)-$)"6.o/2&("'/"8$),*-*.*-$)"
)/*-$)/'&"="TV?'&)*/*-$)")/*-$)/'&" 3+V2$~/)*"'&"(/+/(*s+&"3+-$+-D
*/-+&"%o.)&" 3+$(V%.+&"-)(-%&)*&"%&" ($)*+|'&"%&" ($),*-*.*-$))/'-*V"="
_+*-('&"^b"XCUI"="L-7+&"(-+(.'/*-$)"%&,"3&+,$))&,"="\.33+&,,-$)"%."
($)*+|'&"/.4" 0+$)*-s+&," -)*V+-&.+&,"=" Ts?'&)*" h8Ii")a" G^JuJKK^"
="_+*-('&,"JK" &*"JE" ="TV?'&)*/*-$)")/*-$)/'&" /.*$+-,/)*"%&,"($)D
*+|'&," %o-%&)*-*V" %/)," '/" ;$)&" ($#3+-,&" &)*+&" '/" 0+$)*-s+&" *&++&,*+&"
GHOD )UDQFHDYHFOHV eWDWVSDUWLHV jODFRQYHQWLRQ GDSSOLFDWLRQGH
EH^"TIZ[\X_"S!"OT!YT_W_"SI"S[TI[X!"S_"U][`!"IUT!OI[_
ODFFRUGGH6FKHQJHQHWXQHOLJQHWUDFpHjNLORPqWUHVHQGHojGH
(&**&"0+$)*-s+&t
'DQVOHVDIIDLUHVMRLQWHV&HW&
ayant pour objet des demandes de décision préjudicielle au titre
GHODUWLFOH 7)8(LQWURGXLWHV SDUOD &RXUGH FDVVDWLRQ )UDQFH
par décisions du 16 avril 2010, parvenues à la Cour le même jour, dans
les procédures contre
)[#[/V'=c#0&
RX=#)`*'=#"&
3DUFHVPRWLIVOD&RXUJUDQGHFKDPEUHGLWSRXUGURLW
/DUWLFOH7)8(VRSSRVHjXQHOpJLVODWLRQGXQeWDWPHPEUH
qui instaure une procédure incidente de contrôle de constitutionnalité
des lois nationales, pour autant que le caractère prioritaire de cette
procédure a pour conséquence d’empêcher, tant avant la transmission
d’une question de constitutionnalité à la juridiction nationale chargée
d’exercer le contrôle de constitutionnalité des lois que, le cas échéant,
après la décision de cette juridiction sur ladite question, toutes les
autres juridictions nationales d’exercer leur faculté ou de satisfaire à
leur obligation de saisir la Cour de questions préjudicielles. En revan*
che, l’article 267 TFUE ne s’oppose pas à une telle législation nationale
pour autant que les autres juridictions nationales restent libres:
— de saisir, à tout moment de la procédure qu’elles jugent appro*
prié, et même à l’issue de la procédure incidente de contrôle
de constitutionnalité, la Cour de toute question préjudicielle
qu’elles jugent nécessaire,
©GDGRSWHUWRXWHPHVXUHQpFHVVDLUHD´QGDVVXUHUODSURWHFWLRQ
juridictionnelle provisoire des droits conférés par l’ordre juridi*
que de l’Union, et
— de laisser inappliquée, à l’issue d’une telle procédure incidente,
la disposition législative nationale en cause si elles la jugent
contraire au droit de l’Union.
,ODSSDUWLHQW jOD MXULGLFWLRQGH UHQYRLGHYpUL´HU VLOD OpJLVODWLRQ
nationale en cause au principal peut être interprétée conformément à
ces exigences du droit de l’Union.
/DUWLFOHSDUDJUDSKH 7)8(DLQVLTXHOHV DUWLFOHVHW
GXUqJOHPHQW&(QGX3DUOHPHQWHXURSpHQHWGX&RQVHLO
du 15 mars 2006, établissant un code communautaire relatif au régime
de franchissement des frontières par les personnes (code frontières
6FKHQJHQVRSSRVHQWjXQHOpJLVODWLRQQDWLRQDOHFRQIpUDQWDX[DXWR*
ULWpVGHSROLFHGHOeWDWPHPEUHFRQFHUQpODFRPSpWHQFHGHFRQWU{OHU
"_"TIL_x`!"I]XTI"U][`!"IUT!OI[_"I"_"NUI\X `!"OT[!T[XyT[_""EHb"
"SI"8!]\X[XU8[!]_L[S_SI"S!"S[TI[X!"CT_]8z\
uniquement dans une zone de 20 kilomètres à partir de la frontière ter*
UHVWUHGHFHWeWDW DYHFOHVeWDWVSDUWLHV jODFRQYHQWLRQGDSSOLFDWLRQ
GH ODFFRUG GH 6FKHQJHQ GX MXLQ HQWUH OHV JRXYHUQHPHQWV
GHVeWDWV GH O8QLRQpFRQRPLTXH %HQHOX[GH OD 5pSXEOLTXHIpGpUD*
le d’Allemagne et de la République française relatif à la suppression
graduelle des contrôles aux frontières communes, signée à Schengen
/X[HPERXUJOH MXLQ OLGHQWLWp GHWRXWHSHUVRQQH LQGpSHQ*
damment du comportement de celle*ci et de circonstances particuliè*
UHVpWDEOLVVDQWXQULVTXH GDWWHLQWHjORUGUHSXEOLF HQYXHGHYpUL´HU
le respect des obligations de détention, de port et de présentation des
titres et des documents prévues par la loi, sans prévoir l’encadrement
nécessaire de cette compétence garantissant que l’exercice pratique
de ladite compétence ne puisse pas revêtir un effet équivalent à celui
GHVYpUL´FDWLRQVDX[IURQWLqUHV
S-,3$)@2&'" k"
„F&/b%K0EdK%&&7KK0GHb0F0HcGKHHG0bHH/%Fb%7&b/EA&dc•/4-L(d&N(cKL/46
W7]c!7dc\&K€*&4*„‡%$(-%„HKbcH‡3/?&[)%&4„K‡%$('/)?„0+‡#$%&„',*‡%-
U RFF ´UVWSDUW FLG $FHVVRHPDJR
To continue reading
Request your trial