Max Gutmann v Commission of the European Communities.
| Jurisdiction | European Union |
| ECLI | ECLI:EU:C:1983:286 |
| Court | Court of Justice (European Union) |
| Date | 20 October 1983 |
| Docket Number | 92/82 |
| Celex Number | 61982CJ0092 |
| Procedure Type | Recours de fonctionnaires - non fondé |
Arrêt de la Cour (troisième chambre) du 20 octobre 1983. - Max Gutmann contre Commission des Communautés européennes. - Fonctionnaire - Indemnité de réinstallation - Répétition de l'indu. - Affaire 92/82.
Recueil de jurisprudence 1983 page 03127
Parties
Objet du litige
Motifs de l'arrêt
Décisions sur les dépenses
Dispositif
FONCTIONNAIRES - REPETITION DE L ' INDU - CONDITIONS - CONNAISSANCE PAR L ' INTERESSE DE L ' IRREGULARITE DU VERSEMENT
( STATUT DES FONCTIONNAIRES , ART . 85 )
Parties
DANS L ' AFFAIRE 92/82
MAX GUTMANN , ANCIEN FONCTIONNAIRE DE LA COMMISSION DES COMMUNAUTES EUROPEENNES , DECEDE LE 22 MARS 1982 , AYANT LAISSE POUR SEULES HERITIERES SES DEUX FILLES , MESDEMOISELLES ANNE GUTMANN , ETUDIANTE , DEMEURANT A PARIS ( 75116 ), 95 , RUE DE LA FAISANDERIE , ET ISABELLE GUTMANN , SANS ETAT , RESIDANT A LA MEME ADRESSE , LESQUELLES REPRENNENT L ' INSTANCE INTRODUITE PAR LEUR AUTEUR , CES DERNIERES ETANT ASSISTEES ET REPRESENTEES PAR M VICTOR BIEL , AVOCAT AU BARREAU DE LUXEMBOURG , AYANT SON ETUDE EN LADITE VILLE , 18A , RUE DES GLACIS , CHEZ QUI ELLES FONT ELECTION DE DOMICILE ,
PARTIES REQUERANTES ,
CONTRE
COMMISSION DES COMMUNAUTES EUROPEENNES , REPRESENTEE PAR MONSIEUR HENDRIK VAN LIER , MEMBRE DE SON SERVICE JURIDIQUE , EN QUALITE D ' AGENT , ASSISTE PAR M ROBERT ANDERSEN , AVOCAT AU BARREAU DE BRUXELLES , AVENUE MONTJOIE , 214 A 1180 BRUXELLES , ELISANT DOMICILE A LUXEMBOURG AUPRES DE MONSIEUR ORESTE MONTALTO , MEMBRE DE SON SERVICE JURIDIQUE , BATIMENT JEAN MONNET , PLATEAU DU KIRCHBERG A LUXEMBOURG ,
PARTIE DEFENDERESSE ,
Objet du litige
AYANT POUR OBJET L ' ANNULATION DE LA DECISION DE LA DEFENDERESSE DE PROCEDER SUR BASE DE L ' ARTICLE 85 DU STATUT A LA RECUPERATION DE SOMMES VERSEES AU TITRE D ' UNE INDEMNITE DE REINSTALLATION .
Motifs de l'arrêt
1 PAR REQUETE EN DATE DU 18 MARS 1982 , M . GUTMANN , ANCIEN CONSEILLER A L ' OFFICE DES PUBLICATIONS OFFICIELLES DES COMMUNAUTES EUROPEENNES A LUXEMBOURG , A INTRODUIT UN RECOURS VISANT A L ' ANNULATION DE LA DECISION DE LA COMMISSION , DU 16 JUIN 1981 , ORDONNANT LA RECUPERATION , SUR BASE DE L ' ARTICLE 85 DU STATUT DES FONCTIONNAIRES ( CI-APRES LE STATUT ), DE SOMMES VERSEES AU TITRE D ' UNE INDEMNITE DE REINSTALLATION .
2 M . GUTMANN ETANT DECEDE LE 22 MARS 1982 , L ' INSTANCE A ETE REPRISE PAR SES DEUX FILLES .
3 SUITE A SA MISE...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Opinion of Advocate General Kokott delivered on 17 September 2020.
...Kraft Products and Others (C‑310/97 P, EU:C:1999:407, paragraphs 52 to 55). 35 Judgments of 20 October 1983, Gutmann v Commission (92/82, EU:C:1983:286, paragraph 2), and of 23 April 1986, Les Verts v Parliament (294/83, EU:C:1986:166, paragraphs 15 to 36 Judgments of 8 July 2004, JFE Engin......
-
JFE Engineering Corp., formerly NKK Corp. (T-67/00), Nippon Steel Corp. (T-68/00), JFE Steel Corp. (T-71/00) and Sumitomo Metal Industries Ltd (T-78/00) v Commission of the European Communities.
...person or in the case of a legal person ceasing to exist when all its rights and obligations are vested in a new person (see to that effect Case 92/82 Gutmann v Commission [1983] ECR 3127, paragraph 2, and Case 294/83 Les Verts v Parliament [1986] ECR 1339, paragraphs 13 to 18). It must be ......
-
Hugo Boss AG v Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market (Trade Marks and Designs) (OHIM).
...the cessation of a legal person’s existence whenever all their rights and obligations are transferred to a new owner (see, to that effect, Case 92/82 Gutmann v Commission [1983] ECR 3127, paragraph 2; Case 294/83 Les Verts v Parliament [1986] ECR 1339, paragraphs 13 to 18, and Case C-361/01......
-
Graf Yorck von Wartenburg contra Parlamento Europeo.
...fictitious notwithstanding the production of a certificate of permanent residence issued by the authorities of that city (see Opinion in Case 92/82 [1983] ECR 3127, 3136). Similarly, the Court of Justice has acknowledged that "an official residence permit has a specific function only in con......
-
Opinion of Advocate General Kokott delivered on 17 September 2020.
...Kraft Products and Others (C‑310/97 P, EU:C:1999:407, paragraphs 52 to 55). 35 Judgments of 20 October 1983, Gutmann v Commission (92/82, EU:C:1983:286, paragraph 2), and of 23 April 1986, Les Verts v Parliament (294/83, EU:C:1986:166, paragraphs 15 to 36 Judgments of 8 July 2004, JFE Engin......
-
JFE Engineering Corp., formerly NKK Corp. (T-67/00), Nippon Steel Corp. (T-68/00), JFE Steel Corp. (T-71/00) and Sumitomo Metal Industries Ltd (T-78/00) v Commission of the European Communities.
...person or in the case of a legal person ceasing to exist when all its rights and obligations are vested in a new person (see to that effect Case 92/82 Gutmann v Commission [1983] ECR 3127, paragraph 2, and Case 294/83 Les Verts v Parliament [1986] ECR 1339, paragraphs 13 to 18). It must be ......
-
Hugo Boss AG v Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market (Trade Marks and Designs) (OHIM).
...the cessation of a legal person’s existence whenever all their rights and obligations are transferred to a new owner (see, to that effect, Case 92/82 Gutmann v Commission [1983] ECR 3127, paragraph 2; Case 294/83 Les Verts v Parliament [1986] ECR 1339, paragraphs 13 to 18, and Case C-361/01......
-
Graf Yorck von Wartenburg contra Parlamento Europeo.
...fictitious notwithstanding the production of a certificate of permanent residence issued by the authorities of that city (see Opinion in Case 92/82 [1983] ECR 3127, 3136). Similarly, the Court of Justice has acknowledged that "an official residence permit has a specific function only in con......