Vedial SA v Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market (Trade Marks and Designs) (OHIM).
Jurisdiction | European Union |
Celex Number | 62003CC0106 |
ECLI | ECLI:EU:C:2004:457 |
Court | Court of Justice (European Union) |
Date | 15 July 2004 |
Docket Number | C-106/03 |
Procedure Type | Recurso de anulación |
M. DÁMASO RUIZ-JARABO COLOMER
présentées le 15 juillet 2004(1)
Vedial SA
contre
Office de l'harmonisation dans le marché intérieur
(marques, dessins et modèles)
«Pourvoi – Marque communautaire – Marque verbale et figurative 'HUBERT' – Opposition du titulaire de la marque verbale nationale 'SAINT-HUBERT 41' – Violation du principe dispositif – Violation de la notion de risque de confusion»
Introduction 1. En l'espèce, un intérêt particulier s'attache à la détermination du champ d'application du principe dispositif dans certaines procédures relatives à la marque communautaire, en particulier dans celles portées devant le Tribunal de première instance, lorsque la validité d'une décision administrative dénouant une procédure d'opposition à l'enregistrement d'une marque est en cause. Antécédents du litige 2. Le 1er avril 1996, France Distribution, société établie à Émerainville (France) a présenté, en vertu du règlement (CE) n° 40/94 (2) , une demande de marque communautaire à l'Office de l'harmonisation dans le marché intérieur (marques, dessins et modèles) (ci-après l'«OHMI»), constituée d'un signe mixte, verbal et figuratif, reproduit ci-dessous: iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAAAO8AAAChCAYAAAAvIuilAAAAAXNSR0IArs4c6QAAAAlwSFlz AAAOxAAADsQBlSsOGwAAABl0RVh0U29mdHdhcmUATWljcm9zb2Z0IE9mZmljZX/tNXEAAL3Y SURBVHhe7Z0FgJ9XlfbPeNzd3d3dG627eymlihUK38KyLLBooUq9VIG6pXF3d3efJBO38e/3 nPv+JzORJmlStnTnLUNm/vLKvffcY895TmJOdk6uxZnFxfF/hcc3bgSyM8wSknisCzy9OTlm 8fHnPly5uVprJ3+Pl/NuMfYZ/ZuTzf0nHv98/s/FXs3lXuLy3UtWFt/h7/yv5X02//V1fr6r Q8+ic+dyUd0eUsHv0b3qX50/+juHN7K5r/j4OH+WXD6s+8zmXImJfD+BF/k9Ny58TueLjZXO r2vqnuP5XDyf0Un0us4Tp3NyId0LJ+A+eE0n8Bf4fIKukWC//OUv4xLDiMXZpo3bbf2GDZaZ mcFPDh+K95vL5eLhBDl+QX0+l6vn8Ie+GsdT6eR6ON2AHiA7K84S/Kay+Ts8ObdhmVn6jm5Y I5sdzqtb1cNzTp0rMTHesnjibD01N68HzMrK5l4S+Ewuk6IBCzeS7ffBIGhweKgsLq7PhEFO 8CHQPfl3+D1OA8SHs7K5HveiEdV9+STxf5ma9AQNfjyTwft+mXjL5lkTecgcPZPOwUlyeU3f 42H83LoR/e2vaTy4d11LgxZ7Tr2p33WDGj9fKNxDPOdO4N9Mnln3pY00gXvwCeU1vx+dW/es 7/qc6fewovQ83IavRM1NQmIS969rcD5WlY+yhpwbYmQtTqsnkiCNkcZNIxGfEMbY58LvK7zn 8+yrjV1Az6OFi0Bla4w4ND6aUx9fFzjmK1ELUtfl3l1Cwmey9AycV/ebm6O1ozvQZzVsum4Q Al9s/hr/RGMUW3caWK0LH4voHvR7OE+YBK1d/eRoHnyctS4Zm3jOq+fM5CF0Br0fzWsYMz7D uX0d5d8UNL+aa+4l2yWVdaU14eMXU35hbrWOfcIkM74co9dzuS73m63n9/FI8OfXCPs9avy0 dvy+NEasgTCxLgsZLNA6terYww/d6/fOmgzb4Lw5C+3l1/5m5SuV40UkISz3aDVGqzI+TE54 x/cTBija8nwS/KoabV9XcT6wLCC2zgQJnybEt53w0HpNc5DFYOhvLS4JqSbX14pOo1vQafUg WlSxifaBjL2pD+gc4cl1Z0HIJeBBgCUg/l0GVNf1HdCFiMXs7yf6U/mG5YOYa4ms0LBAtchi i0ALge9zzzpnEIxonHQN3afu2IcsLCLdu0bUFwQf9V1e7/lzJQTBizYybRASJB8Dnzd9gfNq kUkwNWB+jbDr69CzZkfCmpyo/VjPoUUWBDFBqovz6TmzXbok4GHf1um1k2v9avHG87ruX99L YtPQBpnEa1qMWqxhLliA+i08AOPky8U3TD14kk++GTrA5zeBRasx0/0WKZbi3/FV4+OgzTyM YbTvhXmKxlAnikPYXPh1SRfIaE61VnjOsC78tL7p6XxaZprbRDc7NIQ5rDNdkmfkNV0jJycr zLW/ryvx7BonDYY+4Qua33gIH399jofV9fR+ePywzsJSDAOhv31TitS6nltzoXkI60i7gn/S 71Vzos07/6FNQt+TAGvdSC7mzp9n69asCRsUB7MSblTjU61qFXv4ew9b+bKl/QK++bBI/WZ8 kfrcRDfLQ8RGTAtOA6kh9wWqN8IC1ChqQWuxBM0TaSyfu9jNB00frW1/IB+0sMr9fPqsFpK/ Hk22fyq6N98Ywp/hkXR+F8S8U+RtLlrY+pzek9bQV9wa8O/Hrhmu415FNNDhAy7ivrgimcsT Xr+eLh8NgZtBsWfhw7HnC+PoJw2njG7Z/9R3IxPO/wzynvcpHxudK6Y8fYIl2D76ec8cfazA 56LLnWTu7tlzyD786EPbtmWb1W/YyC655GIrUVzzWXh8nUagaJEUG/HZ55H15sIbLSBmtmjR FKterbKVKlH063TPhfeSNwIx8eOFE2XL955870ffOZVfunlLqi1avMQ1jZTyogXzbdSoEXbw 4GErXXaK7dm7x2rXroWJm2V169W31i0aFM7BWY1ApDVONV/+2onvn8VJY+YIs5WFS+s+cTTN ecLr3h+TlZFOhAPhjanmszh94Ue+5iOQPxjJ/Ntzz71oU6ZMJJCV7POcnXnMfWuZz4cPH7R3 /vG2+9m5uAzVq9ey2++4y6pWrWz169Vgg08OyzAy3b7mj/6/fHtfQlhPdceRJZdELEN+u7tf HIkxEy8+ST7pKTfv/+UBKLz8lx6BaO1I0A4ePGpzZs6xLZjGK5cucncoHklW8EXauXb9Btap azcrVqyI2+3SunNnzCCQucUef/z3Vr5MOfve939gjRvVtSIIsLykQvn90jPz5b4o/1eB3pjw xs4iPzD4o8F3LDy+GSMgM2v7tl325BNP2cLFi+zIkcNoWAxmRZmY6qIpRe3Sy6+yQUMGWr26 1QsY3oMHDLRdu/fYRx9+aJMnjbennvqLVa5cxR588AGrWq18iJCebKl/Mwbua/gUHhglwuhx JWne2D0maitV6iWW+Poa3nzhLZ16BE6bo2euV6/eZO+9/4HNnDvbMjLSo0h7sLASkuLs0ssu tzvuuBlzOERl8x81alQy/RQvep3NmzvTVqxaZZu2brOX//a6XXnVFda0Ue1C8/lfuCiTk3Fz ouxJAeH1sH0sWvwvvKHCS53fCHwRuEb78IRxE+3z4Z94NiEBn5Ycj+eT48i7xJMaatq8uQvu 6XxYZRnqN6htd951j73+xusezBo18nNLTkyxhMuGWcNGtQrt5/ObwrP+tidflDuOvnEcu6Ks DtlmASIKj/+9EYjFIM50BzGh3Z12wD547xM7duxYACbwRbk+MrEOHzpiU6ZN8jxwLN2mPKbc o6KJRez6G262hg3rfaH21Iau3OnQIYNt/JgxtmvXLktMSrHPRw635cuX2A9/+H1r2pRzxPJg Z7rxwve/9Ah4utYl9wSzOYGtOZZw/tJnL/ziOY1A3jwcT/nm5dJPeyLPA8fZho1bbRu+7Phx Y12QQj46Bi5QDjoguJIQNAEUNN/amLOzs/Bbq1nfPv3t2muusWLFT691j9+DBNisCVp62eqV HoUWTGPbto22Y/sOF95TZKnOaSwKP3zmEXAZ9c05fDZP8yY4EkX7bKHmPfMwnv8nAvCF4xQB nwDXO/U1JLipqWn2h9/+yVaCtpGQphQRYkjTJ6QV2CciyJpPxS+yczOxqAISqGKFypaSnGSt 2rS1+x+8N6CCziJkrI8kEODq17evfT7iczt08JDFEfQSzO/9Dz/w6Gf/Ad3zQDDnPzqFZzjV CCSREXJgkaDD+YXXYWdMgmNPC4+vbARi5u7GDVtt3Yb1AZYpTLL+Y2ZKFC9hHTq2ibRowduI fXfatJm2as0KsNhZHjmWu5OZnumCXLVqdStbtrxt2rTOihQpau06dbHSpUr5ZtC9V0+rTr42 KQkA41kKbv47kDkezHI2iOwE1kqmzZk/i3tIwnduCkKv3JeBIXxlY/2NO7Gj+46j9vI0rzZ6 ATUKQ/9f3ZRL+A4dOWYH9h+0z4aPsvfffy9AISW8DlIn31qjFmmY/7SaNSuepBUzMjJt/brt NhZTOSP7GJjiZFA32VayREmr1bSmcPA2dNgl1rRZM9u0eZMVSSliLVu3sGJF85XlRI93Nhq3 oODmWo2a1ezSSy6zd99/x46kH3NfWpC9hYsX2LN/fd4e+M63MMkR4LPQ5l/dKH9zz+yFChLf KCOUDx7pcPg8LO43dwj+d55MgpuOdnzzjXds8tSptn/vbm4k21o0b2MNGtQnlTMHQMQGtPE6 Gz1qDNHdG/Lw125d8/2dO3fbn//8Z1u9biXBKRVNZAL8j7dbbr7FBpOnVTVPqdKlHHRRt161 kx80AuF/2REoUaKY3XzrjR61fvvtt+zw0SOkm1TIkGWTJo9zc+6B73zbqkU54C97ncLvnXoE vAJKgeUTfd5kTCmtlhh6o3AAz38ETgSsrVuzGcEca3vSdlqTZk2tT/9+1r1rV0zZcpb5eJZt XLeeFEwClTenxpbv2rnHtu/YYsdARqlap3ixEta2TXu7aOBAK1WqeN4Nf1WaT+dNTk6wa6+7 mmhJsk2aMMHWrF/rJrjWzZTJk92Ef/CBe616jcqFGvj8l1CBM8QqqmIRq+MBq1AT5WVyhcf5 jUBeJVG+0+xM3Wevvfaa7du/0wYNGmK33nYz/mlZ/4RXb6FFszMybMDgi+3iYYPlWeZFFXW+ 1Ws32quvvkr6Zz9lbnFWvEgRu/HGW+3SS4fgJ//rsOgSYOGbb7v5amtYr4799re/tQOHDnp5 n0oGZ8ycZt26sCHVuOj8BrHw2yeNgBf/u4SekCry0rl86I3CsTv3EYgJ7b79h0mjpHKCUNun cselS5ba7PlzrFKlCpi4g/IEV1dZtWqjzZoz2ypVrmhDLx6CFi1yktbasGaDLV68mA3WK9XR tsPsmmsut+SkULT/rzwCLDLO2rRtaZ06d7RRo0e5Ge8EAtzI4qXLrG792taiRcN/5W19468V auej4ml+Ox7JiErK4mIG9Td+KC7sA2oxHztKNJZxnDFtjr3w8kvAUAPNCeXhln403bII8rRv 35GA0vESuwMHjtrIESPtCICKe79znzVv3uCUwlgETVuufHnbv38vQap0gke18wT3f6OeRAJc jBLSAQMusgUL5tmutL0OmodewcaNH0khxAH77//+qWOo/9Wby4Wd2a/P2aQERDqhXL2O4yWB TgkTo2n5+tzwv8OdSHDXr99ir778uh08vN9270y1XTu3+aJ1wRJnDL+1a9sOM/eyPKHT9yaM m2SffPKRla9QAcFuVyBIFXt2naddhzb24x89an/68x9s85attnrVclu+ooE1bdIgIgU4P+0b sxrORdBUw1K3Tj0rV7YcBQwE4JxBBfYNFpcDQwqRGxd0+brOzcfUkE94RVUSUbhc0Et+s0+m Rb9pUyoVN3+1WbNnwGeUaeVKl7OKFSsp8QZIItsOU8mTmZ4OxPBia9igVlSNE4eA7yFKO97p WNq370TKR4GqUwth8eIpFMjXQJMV8QjziBHDLXXHLnv00R+SXw2+89kfp04JHjuaTblfoAg6 m8N5scSJ5YuK9YPWDeRq4jLLjJ6lsOzobMbyrD7jAx5RBOXXvE45I+E9y4k7q4t9wz8kwd26 Zac9+dTTNnvWDKtQsTw+YHcCTkOsZMkSPL3odnJs0cIlNnrMKFu3fp0dPdo5r6B99+69tmbd Oq+pbdGiuRUvfrKvm38IpcucTciFxmzFiqX2I7DFt952O+Zrr0hrn17wYtpV8HXlhxfDpqGc szi9dqfttm1bd9g1115NnrnsWa8DXU2RZo+X8KwqTlP1i1fAfMPn/1/9eIJHCpceq/w7XhJI isKJu6g0KTzOPAIShI1o3Gee/avNmTvLulLI3qx5C7v6mitJ4RQERdSuVdXKlytrz73wvA0c 2A9GCipxJIjkSJOBK8ocSs84duqLCsvsOeJsr8vNyhD1m8jkNIlot4ip8EzgGp1DLJNr128F Dz2OovzNtmzZMnzo/c5iGIj4sm33njS7D7BF1SpfDLaIwJ02b95825G6w3JFYyqTmYj5oIGD 7brrrnQ8dKEyOPNaOttPxIgBlc/39ZP3RY82i8mxUHjPPJjQcCJM777znk0DcMHSt3btO9hl lMgVKXKy2SnBSUJIa1arZaUBUcQOxx7jH4odUdHaEw9HvUUkeh9+MNw+/Ph9gBpbrUzJstar Zy+rBc9Uzx49rUqVUBh/uiOmcbdu2+mpnXVrV0Pvm8U9cedALLOzxIhJCiglhVzteCqUMqgW ehjTX0SEpwNZm23fnmZjxoy3g4eOuvYW+0ZNaHOGDh0ESCS4B4XHBRwBDafk9ESQhqgnxYXr dLiFxxeOgLTcMtIhs2dNQ1iTgARWtdJlSrrg5o3sCWeoR060SdMmtnXzditfvoybvcWKFqFY oIKl7dlru3fvcn8xRj2rr0sjHyVKvXLFWhs5coRt2LTBzeb2TZvZPd/6NpjlwCel47QyFqnk 8WOn2sfDh9sWzqGXRA6uHbx27dqOhxYzp4JPWRTsb9y81WbPmW8DL+rpvFYnCqE2g+3bd9nT zz5nCxYtwIKQ4Gagravatx+431q1bloouF+BDGkulOOPYZgLVBU5vWqkkr+Ca3+jTukCR21r iTJl7K67v2VdO7f5wgVbFjrdvXvT7IP3P0KIG1lKSoJVq17FunTuxkawxMbiE3cF3NCsaR0P dHmc2qPYW+2JJ54kwrzRimBmN2nczG6/9bY8wT0bjTtxwjR75q9/tS3bt4J3TnKBLFWygsVD qXLJsMvtsisuDjzNyYGf+QAskuvXbcDMVuGDMNcFd/Rjx7Js7NiJNm3KZK9Cy+FztWvVt299 617r3qX9N2qev04Po1TRcS71fGazaISdhryQw+qM86VgT2rqLo8aKY9brqy0bmBiPN2xYf1m mw9pdps27Vy76hCBen2I35o3a23rNq23P/75cRsK+uriYQMchqhDvu2+/Xtgv4D2Ec3cEF7l ps3qR9r2i0zl0EFi/Lip9tJLL1FEn0oRgdgHs61Ktar23e/+yJFZFSuUpUwwlvyXuo/jeUpY ufYt/BoqMhPd1d69B23lsrW+uU+ZNtXmL5jra6VRo8ZWt25d69G9l/Xo2emM93XGwS38wGlH wHHNItJXGxOO44UJvAOPYOg6UHicdgSkhfbuO2STJk5iYdPCJSML0/Y0waZ8Z0nducvq1Wtg V197FSV5x6P6PXt1trLlK9hjP33Mli1eaLu3bbdOndpZTbijwhGYLIzWIFlM2hGKATIIWqVE wn36qUJ7M8djQD9t3k6FEdFf+bdFwLAPAp3Vrl3TvK+eyiyWCb89da8Tse/DylgAt/P4CeN9 41HqK5c64UoU9V8Ged3QIf1Oe67CpXQBR0AyGrUJKiC8XsUrUEFe75cLeNFv2KlkYqaDllLR e+XKlYkkl/tCYVeN9Lix461B/XrkZCsU0NCpqbttxXJqc4+lW4UK5a1jpw4uaHlHBInT/JQs Udxq16kT/OIvSMQ42utIuk2eMosAV6oHpBWgSsEEvu66m9hArjy9huS769ZutvHjJ9mMGdPR uHvt6JEjdhSaHd/Xde2cDGvcuKl95/4HrAkgkdhRGKD6ahe6elAlENg8KWAVGj6F/j2FxxeP QKxTm/pNNWIRV6tR/aQveKQ4MmKmTJ5lU6dOQlOV98/pZUdeISjz5i62l174q2OWO7Tvat// wXfdvI3hh72fjRcpZFtxhLdFy9b0DjpNPj4fTnLlqvWemtqVtoNeQfGY9Sl2OVryxptvwO89 PRBD97aO6qYpkyd6Y7Wy5cpYRfDY+/fvsx07tnvhfeUqNb2SqTWBqbDnF66Zf4XMeFA56llV QPMmUeLlDbgKqV/POA9COCkdHocmm0cd7nI0Z4d2wUeMHUFw4whETaXo/kPrTDCqUeMmYbFH gnvsaIatWbUSWpl9dsVV19sdd96eJ7ix82hOlE6SgKSBHx43erS1btmoQFQ65ugEDjIzlLhN pFxv187taF2lo3KsWbOOdvNNN50ylVXwgXOtR48u1rYtbB48hCLJSmNtxnx+glri9bB/3HHn /da3b6eg/Qvl9ozr5UJ9QFREijNkq4cpx/HkIrMuyY51RrtQF/ymncepakoWs57duwN02GCH Dh2iIIFg0klHKJyeNXOmNW/S2L7z0N0naamPP/qcqO0Ya92qPZVGQ6CvKX6CFssF7VQJQRlk H376AbnlYzZ9+iRrO6Gt9evXLS8KHOvttm37HmqF99iE8RNsJlBNuF39M0LlxAPoEGVO7Min pI/fuQIi/Kgjgn7yH00b1wGb3RaQx1rbQa555649VqniucIyv2mr4V/7PCrGV0pP9EMFhNdB 9AIN/Gvv59/yakJFNYezKWYAq5+w61nhTiMT0v/l73vvu5tobcGuYA6rBOAwdvx4awO445GH H7YyZU+uydUpSpQsarfdfjMab41NnzXTdlIA8Mxfn7VN21PxtytaJ6qUitI2c/nSFfb0M3/2 fPE+TNxcospqKSnQTXG4rFoCv/TAV0xVRkqzQBYolHSfIq/rT+cGvAJ0b7zxivc0uvvOW88I yfy3nOCv6U17ClEyeqLmTVQOSc2U1WG68DjjCCQiwKUgi9t7cD9Iq3dtL5po6LD+MDnmA60h feXKHUdUxQRcAazJ4yfbypXLrVGThi64sff0r9IBEqpgkUrTy1+9zLZs3cLPJuhWN9tzzzxh JUqUtlat2kLfWsQ2Qp+zZvVqZCybaLZMXTUIz0awi9vVV19t1954I+knBTvCWU+EU0Z7zSmf...
To continue reading
Request your trial1 practice notes
-
Opinion of Advocate General Tanchev delivered on 19 December 2019.
...EU:C:2018:635, paragraph 52 and the case-law cited); Opinions of Advocate General Ruiz-Jarabo Colomer in Vedial v OHIM (C‑106/03 P, EU:C:2004:457, points 28 to 30); of Advocate General Kokott in Duarte Hueros (C‑32/12, EU:C:2013:128, point 32); and of Advocate General Mengozzi in British Ai......
1 cases
-
Opinion of Advocate General Tanchev delivered on 19 December 2019.
...EU:C:2018:635, paragraph 52 and the case-law cited); Opinions of Advocate General Ruiz-Jarabo Colomer in Vedial v OHIM (C‑106/03 P, EU:C:2004:457, points 28 to 30); of Advocate General Kokott in Duarte Hueros (C‑32/12, EU:C:2013:128, point 32); and of Advocate General Mengozzi in British Ai......