Carmine Capolongo v Azienda Agricole Maya.
Jurisdiction | European Union |
ECLI | ECLI:EU:C:1973:65 |
Date | 19 June 1973 |
Celex Number | 61972CJ0077 |
Court | Court of Justice (European Union) |
Procedure Type | Reference for a preliminary ruling |
Docket Number | 77-72 |
Arrêt de la Cour du 19 juin 1973. - Carmine Capolongo contre Azienda Agricole Maya. - Demande de décision préjudicielle: Pretura di Conegliano - Italie. - Contributo ente nazionale per la cellulosa e per la carta. - Affaire 77-72.
Recueil de jurisprudence 1973 page 00611
édition spéciale grecque page 00567
édition spéciale portugaise page 00253
édition spéciale espagnole page 00189
édition spéciale suédoise page 00109
édition spéciale finnoise page 00109
Sommaire
Parties
Objet du litige
Motifs de l'arrêt
Décisions sur les dépenses
Dispositif
1 . AIDES ACCORDEES PAR LES ETATS - SUPPRESSION - EFFET DIRECT - CONDITIONS
( TRAITE CEE , ART . 92 , PARAGRAPHE 1 )
2 . QUESTIONS PREJUDICIELLES - COMPETENCES DE LA COUR - LIMITES
( TRAITE CEE , ART . 177 )
3 . DROITS DE DOUANE - TAXES D ' EFFET EQUIVALENT - SUPPRESSION - EFFET DIRECT
( TRAITE CEE , ART . 13 , PARAGRAPHE 2 )
4 . DROITS DE DOUANE - TAXES D ' EFFET EQUIVALENT - NOTION
( TRAITE CEE , ART . 13 , PARAGRAPHE 2 )
Sommaire
1 . EN CE QUI CONCERNE LES AIDES EXISTANT DANS LES ETATS MEMBRES , LE PARAGRAPHE 1 DE L ' ARTICLE 92 EST DESTINE A AVOIR EFFET DANS L ' ORDRE JURIDIQUE DES ETATS MEMBRES , DE MANIERE A POUVOIR ETRE INVOQUE DEVANT LES JURIDICTIONS NATIONALES , S ' IL EST CONCRETISE PAR LES ACTES DE PORTEE GENERALE PREVUS PAR L ' ARTICLE 94 OU PAR LES DECISIONS , DANS LES CAS PARTICULIERS QU ' ENVISAGE L ' ARTICLE 93 , PARAGRAPHE 2 .
2 . DANS L ' EXERCICE DES POUVOIRS CONFERES PAR L ' ARTICLE 177 , LA COUR DEVANT SE BORNER A DONNER UNE INTERPRETATION DES DISPOSITIONS EN CAUSE DU DROIT COMMUNAUTAIRE , NE PEUT APPRECIER LES ACTES JURIDIQUES ET LES DISPOSITIONS DE DROIT NATIONAL , AU RISQUE DE VOIR LA REPONSE NE CORRESPONDRE QU ' IMPARFAITEMENT AUX PARTICULARITES DE L ' ESPECE .
3 . L ' ARTICLE 13 , PARAGRAPHE 2 , COMPORTE , AU PLUS TARD A PARTIR DE LA FIN DE LA PERIODE DE TRANSITION , EN CE QUI CONCERNE L ' ENSEMBLE DES TAXES D ' EFFET EQUIVALANT A DES DROITS DE DOUANE , UNE INTERDICTION CLAIRE ET PRECISE DE PERCEVOIR LESDITES TAXES , QUI N ' EST ASSORTIE D ' AUCUNE RESERVE DES ETATS DE SUBORDONNER SA MISE EN OEUVRE A UN ACTE POSITIF DE DROIT INTERNE OU A UNE INTERVENTION DES INSTITUTIONS DE LA COMMUNAUTE .
CETTE INTERDICTION SE PRETE PARFAITEMENT , PAR SA NATURE MEME , A PRODUIRE DES EFFETS DIRECTS DANS LES RELATIONS JURIDIQUES ENTRE LES ETATS MEMBRES ET LEURS JUSTICIABLES .
4 . TOUTE TAXE EXIGEE A L ' OCCASION OU EN RAISON DE L ' IMPORTATION ET QUI , FRAPPANT SPECIFIQUEMENT UN PRODUIT IMPORTE A L ' EXCLUSION DU PRODUIT NATIONAL SIMILAIRE , A POUR RESULTAT , EN ALTERANT SON PRIX DE REVIENT , D ' AVOIR SUR LA LIBRE CIRCULATION DES MARCHANDISES LA MEME INCIDENCE RESTRICTIVE QU ' UN DROIT DE DOUANE , EST INTERDITE , MEME SI ELLE EST DESTINEE A FINANCER L ' ACTIVITE D ' UN ORGANISME PUBLIC .
PAR CONTRE , LES CHARGES PECUNIAIRES NE CONSTITUENT PAS DES TAXES D ' EFFET EQUIVALENT LORSQU ' ELLES RELEVENT D ' UN REGIME GENERAL DE REDEVANCES INTERIEURES PERCUES SYSTEMATIQUEMENT SUR LES PRODUITS NATIONAUX ET LES PRODUITS IMPORTES SELON LES...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Compagnie Commerciale de l'Ouest y otros contra Receveur principal des douanes de La Pallice Port.
...equivalent effect. With regard to customs duties and charges having equivalent effect on imports, the Court stated, in its judgment in Case 77/72 Capolongo [1973] ECR 611, that in principle that prohibition covers all charges levied at the time of, or by reason of, importation, which are im......
-
CRT France International SA v Directeur régional des impôts de Bourgogne.
...in Case 24/68 Commission v Italy [1969] ECR 193, paragraph 9 and Joined Cases 2/69 and 3/69 Diamantarbeiders [1969] ECR 211, paragraph 18, Case 77/72 Capolongo v Azienda Agricole Maya [1973] ECR 611, Case 158/82 Commission v Denmark [1983] ECR 3573, paragraph 18, and the abovementioned deci......
-
Traghetti del Mediterraneo SpA v Repubblica italiana.
...to a great extent merely reproduces the Court’s existing case-law on the subject. 6 – See, in particular, Case 6/64 Costa [1964] ECR 1141; Case 77/72 Capolongo [1973] ECR 611, paragraph 6; Case 120/73 Lorenz [1973] ECR 1471, paragraph 8; Case C-354/90 Fédération nationale du commerce extéri......
-
Visserijbedrijf D. J. Koornstra & Zn. vof v Productschap Vis.
...and that of imported products – see, for example, Case 94/74 IGAV [1975] ECR 699; Compagnie commerciale de l’Ouest (cited in footnote 10); Case 77/72 Capolongo [1973] ECR 61; Case 78/76 Steinike [1977] ECR 595; Case 77/76 Cucchi [1977] ECR 987; Case 105/76 Interzuccheri [1977] ECR 1029; Com......
-
Compagnie Commerciale de l'Ouest y otros contra Receveur principal des douanes de La Pallice Port.
...equivalent effect. With regard to customs duties and charges having equivalent effect on imports, the Court stated, in its judgment in Case 77/72 Capolongo [1973] ECR 611, that in principle that prohibition covers all charges levied at the time of, or by reason of, importation, which are im......
-
CRT France International SA v Directeur régional des impôts de Bourgogne.
...in Case 24/68 Commission v Italy [1969] ECR 193, paragraph 9 and Joined Cases 2/69 and 3/69 Diamantarbeiders [1969] ECR 211, paragraph 18, Case 77/72 Capolongo v Azienda Agricole Maya [1973] ECR 611, Case 158/82 Commission v Denmark [1983] ECR 3573, paragraph 18, and the abovementioned deci......
-
Traghetti del Mediterraneo SpA v Repubblica italiana.
...to a great extent merely reproduces the Court’s existing case-law on the subject. 6 – See, in particular, Case 6/64 Costa [1964] ECR 1141; Case 77/72 Capolongo [1973] ECR 611, paragraph 6; Case 120/73 Lorenz [1973] ECR 1471, paragraph 8; Case C-354/90 Fédération nationale du commerce extéri......
-
Visserijbedrijf D. J. Koornstra & Zn. vof v Productschap Vis.
...and that of imported products – see, for example, Case 94/74 IGAV [1975] ECR 699; Compagnie commerciale de l’Ouest (cited in footnote 10); Case 77/72 Capolongo [1973] ECR 61; Case 78/76 Steinike [1977] ECR 595; Case 77/76 Cucchi [1977] ECR 987; Case 105/76 Interzuccheri [1977] ECR 1029; Com......
-
Italy
...that the public tender procedures were invalid. ----------------------------- [253] See Case C-6/64, Costa v ENEL [1964] ECR 585 and Case C-77/72, Capolongo v Azienda Agricola Maya [1973] ECR Both decisions were rendered as a preliminary ruling and concern the interpretation of Articles 92 ......
-
France
...[87] cannot be regarded in isolation, but must be considered within the framework of the scheme of Article [87] to [89]", para. 5 of Case C-77/72, Capolongo v Maya [1973] ECR 611. It can be inferred from this case and from the Steinicke case mentioned below that, if Article 87 is invoked be......
-
Summary of Findings, Recommendations, Comparative Legal Analysis
...Pape, not yet reported and Case C-174/02, Streekgewest Westelijk Noord-Brabant, not yet reported. [17] Case C-39/94 cited above. [18] Case C-77/72 Carmine Capolongo v Azienda Agricole Maya [1973] ECR 611. [19] Case C-142/87, Belgium v Commission [1990] ECR I-959; Case C-480/98, Spain v Comm......
-
Austria
...Case C-431/93, Jeoren van Schijndel and Johannes Nicholaas Cornelis van Veen v Stichting [1995] ECR I-4705. [45] See, for assistance, Case C-77/72, Capolongo v Maya [1973] ECR 611, Case C-74/76, Ianelli v Meroni [1977] ECR 557 and the Notice on cooperation between national courts and the Co......
-
2005/474/ECEC: Commission Decision of 14 December 2004 concerning the levy on meat purchases (rendering levy) implemented in France (notified under document number C(2004) 4770)
...published). (52) Commission communication on the method used for setting the reference and discount rates (OJ C 273, 9.9.1997, p. 3). (53) Case 77/72 Carmine Capolongo v Azienda Agricola Maya [1973] ECR (54) Case 120/73 Gebrueder Lorenz GmbH v Germany [1973] ECR 1471. (55) Case 78/76 Steini......
-
Decision of the EEA Joint Committee No 131/2012 of 13 July 2012 amending Annex XIII (Transport) to the EEA Agreement
...0,58 % of the total amount slaughtered. (62) Case C-234/99, referred to in footnote 56 above. (63) OJ C 119, 22.5.2002, p. 22. (64) Case C-77/72 [1973] ECR 611; Case 120/73 [1973] ECR 1471; Case 78/76 [1977] ECR (65) Case 354/90 Fédération nationale du commerce extérieur des produits alimen......
-
2000/628/EC: Commission Decision of 11 April 2000 on the aid granted by Italy to Centrale del Latte di Roma (notified under document number C(2000) 1173) (Only the Italian text is authentic)
...laid down in Article 88(3) of the Treaty, the direct effect of which has been recognised by the Court of Justice in its judgments in Case 77/72 (Carmine Capolongo v Azienda Agricola Maya)(24), Case 120/73 (Gebr. Lorenz GmbH v Federal Republic of Germany)(25) and Case 78/76 (Steinicke und We......
-
2000/206/EC: Commission Decision of 20 July 1999 on an aid scheme applied in Greece to cotton by the Greek Cotton Board (notified under document number C(1999) 2536) (Only the Greek text is authentic)
...set out in Article 88(3) of the Treaty, of which the Court of Justice has recognised the direct effect in its Judgments of 19 June 1973 (Case 77/72 Carmine Capolongo v. Azienda Agricola Maya(11)), 11 December 1973 (Case 120/73 Gebr. Lorenz GmbH v. Federal Republic of Germany(12)) and 22 Mar......